Addicted to Antibiotics: How Factory Farm Drug Abuse Makes Vets Rich
It's no secret that factory farms use unconscionable amounts of antibiotics when fattening up animals for market. In Germany, however, veterinarians play a crucial role in the abuse. Many are getting rich in the process, but the risks to both human and animals are many.
When Almera the cow suffers from twisted bowel or Avatar the llama shows signs of tuberculosis, Björn Seelig is on the scene. He is a veterinarian in the Taunus Mountains, north of Frankfurt, and one of Germany's best-known veterinarians. He demonstrates his dexterity in an afternoon television show on Germany's VOX channel.
The idyllic scenes are deceptive. Many of Seelig's fellow veterinarians, with access to an entire battery of drugs on the shelves of their practices, take a completely different approach. In the past, veterinarians, including those in Seelig's practice, used these drugs in abundance and on a large scale. Indeed, a year and a half ago, three veterinarians in his practice were ordered to pay fines totalling 90,000 ($117,000).
They had sold huge quantities of drugs, some of which were not approved, and dispensed dozers of liters of medications to animals to which they should never have been administered. Investigators with the public prosecutor's office in the western city of Wiesbaden called the operation a "pharmacy on wheels." Antibiotics were allegedly stored on pallets. A former employee told investigators at the time that the veterinary clinic was essentially a mail-order operation for drugs, and that the pharmaceutical industry had expressed its gratitude by giving the clinic huge discounts.
The Taunus trio's operation was particularly shameless, but regulators have uncovered hundreds of similar cases in recent years. Most were treated as minor infractions and the offenders were ordered to pay small fines, if they were punished at all. The fault lies with prescription drug laws that have been relatively malleable until now, and with a system that rewards those who prescribe drugs in large quantities.
'Bigger Profits than Cocaine Dealers'
"Some veterinarians' profit margins are bigger than those of cocaine dealers," says Nicki Schirm, who has been a veterinarian in the state of Hesse for more than 25 years. When a veterinarian finds a sick chick among 20,000 other chicks, he treats the discovery as justification to preventively treat the entire flock with antibiotics, says Rupert Ebner, a veterinarian from the Bavarian city of Ingolstadt. "Nowadays, flock or herd health monitoring is the code name for the generous administration of drugs," says Ebner. In many cases, he adds, fake diagnoses are used to provide a justification for the use of antibiotics.
In large veterinary practices, profits from the sale of drugs can account for up to 80 percent of revenues. This is mainly due to the volume discounts offered by the pharmaceutical industry and the sweet privilege known as the right to dispense -- a special provision for the pharmaceutical monopoly. For more than 150 years, veterinarians have been allowed to both prescribe and sell medications -- with almost no supervision whatsoever.
But this could change. Veterinarians have come into the political firing line after testing of animal populations in the western states of Lower Saxony and North Rhine-Westphalia revealed the large-scale presence of antibiotics. In North Rhine-Westphalia, Green Party Environment Minister Johannes Remmel ordered the testing of 182 flocks on commercial chicken farms. More than 90 percent of the animals had been treated with antibiotics, many multiple times, so that they were essentially being fed a constant diet of drugs. Others were given the medications for only one or two days, which isn't long enough and is in violation of the conditions for licensing the drugs. Such results raise suspicions that the drugs were being used to guarantee the success of the poultry fattening operation rather than to fight disease.
Both farmers and veterinarians are now under suspicion, prompting Agriculture Minister Ilse Aigner to push for a tightening of Germany's Pharmaceutical Products Act and a "careful review" of veterinarians' right to dispense drugs.
The veterinarians' lobby has countered the effort with a petition to preserve the privilege. They speak of their professional honor and independence. But how independent are veterinarians who, for example, are members of the management of giant poultry marketers in Lower Saxony while at the same time monitoring poultry flocks?
There seems to be a great temptation to take laxer approach to dispensing lucrative antibiotics than professional standards would dictate. "In nine out of 10 cases in which a farmer asks for penicillin, he gets the drug right away, without an examination," says veterinarian Ebner, who was one of the top officials in his industry for years. Ebner is a former member of the conservative Christian Social Union (CSU) but now works for the Greens, writing draft legislation that goes beyond what Aigner, a member of the CSU, is calling for. Ebner proposes a ban on volume discounts for drugs in favor of fixed prices; he would also like a requirement that veterinary consulting services be billed separately from drugs.
The debate over the right to dispense is about more than cutting back a few professional privileges. The general effectiveness of antibiotics is on the line. There is only a limited number of agents and humans are dependant on them too. The more these drugs are used in livestock farming, the greater the risk that bacteria will develop new survival strategies, or greater resistance.
Although many of these drug-resistant pathogens originate in hospitals, factory farming also contains a risk of transmission. Animal rights activists with the organization Friends of the Earth Germany (BUND) recently discovered drug-resistant bugs, bacteria that could pose a threat to humans -- in chicken meat on supermarket shelves. Out of 20 samples of chicken meat from major producers like Wiesenhof, 10 contained strains of bacteria that could result in an infected patient no longer responding to certain antibiotics.
Wiesenhof noted that it conducts extensive hygiene testing of its own meat, and that it has cut antibiotic use in half in the last 20 years. The company did not provide any proof, however.
The BUND discoveries admittedly came from a random sample. But even before the discoveries were made, the Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) examined chickens in factory farms and found resistant bacteria in all of them. The normally restrained BfR scientists urgently recommended scrutinizing the overuse of drugs in animal husbandry.
What has the scientists particularly concerned is that more and more pathogens, especially in poultry meat, are immune to several antibiotics, including fluoroquinolones, which, as so-called reserve antibiotics, are supposed to be used sparingly. But pharmaceutical companies have been anything but sparing in recent years when it comes to the use of antibiotics. In 2010, drug maker Bayer earned 166 million, an 11 percent increase over the previous year, with sales of the animal antibiotic Baytril, which is often used with turkeys when all else fails. Annual sales of veterinary drugs in Germany have climbed to 730 million.
As factory farming has grown, so have veterinary practices, sometimes to enormous proportions. Some of these "animal clinics" now have staffs of 20 to 30 people. In some cases, their in-house pharmacies have grown large enough to fill large storage rooms, says a senior veterinarian with a state regulatory agency.
- Part 1: How Factory Farm Drug Abuse Makes Vets Rich
- Part 2: Heavy Reliance on Drugs
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2012
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH
Click on the links below for more information about DER SPIEGEL's history, how to subscribe or purchase the latest issue of the German-language edition in print or digital form or how to obtain rights to reprint SPIEGEL articles.
- Frequently Asked Questions: Everything You Need to Know about DER SPIEGEL
- Six Decades of Quality Journalism: The History of DER SPIEGEL
- A New Home in HafenCity: SPIEGEL's New Hamburg HQ
- Reprints: How To License SPIEGEL Articles