How an Auto Lobbyist Directs EU Policy: The Power Broker Behind the Franco-German CO2 Deal
France and Germany recently reached a compromise on CO2 emission limits for automobiles. The man behind the agreement is Matthias Wissmann -- a former transport minister turned auto industry lobbyist.
VDA President Matthias Wissmann is the most powerful lobbyist in Germany.
For over a year now, Wissmann has served as president of the German Association of the Automotive Industry (VDA), voice of BMW, Daimler, VW, Porsche and around 600 other companies. No other lobbyist in Germany is more powerful. After all, no other industry is as important as the car industry, which is responsible for 290 billion ($449 billion) in annual revenue and 750,000 jobs. Wissmann is the mouthpiece for an industry which is responsible for almost one in seven German jobs. Few people in Germany are so influential.
an agreement on automobile CO2 emission limits. The European Commission’s original recommendations were considerably watered down. Among other things, the transition period will now be seven years rather than the original four.
But Wissmann wasn’t present at the discussion table in Straubing. He had an even better seat for the negotiations: inside the heads of those involved.
The compromise reached by Merkel and Sarkozy fit rather neatly with Wissmann’s wishes. In the fight between German cars and climate protection, Wissmann wants the cars to win -- and he has largely gotten what he wanted.
German automobile manufacturers, who mainly produce heavy, highly polluting sedans, have bought themselves a great deal of time with the longer transition period. Yes, they could develop newer and more fuel efficient technology. But they could also expand their fleets with a few compact cars or hybrids, reducing the fleet’s average consumption.
“The agreement is a considerable improvement over the European Commission’s recommendation,” Wissmann said after the compromise emerged, although he immediately added that it is “still not an ideal solution” -- something the nature of his job requires him to say. Within his association, talk was of “success,” but one of the most important rules of lobbying is not to talk about success publicly. Lobbying is a quiet business; The art of it lies in getting politicians to make the desired decisions, while making it look like they arrived at those decisions on their own.
Wissmann is a master of this art. He knows the other side, having served as a member of the Bundestag, Germany’s parliament, for 31 years. Under former Chancellor Helmut Kohl, Wissmann was a speaker on economic issues for the parliamentary group of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) before becoming minister for research and later transport minister.
Wissmann left the Bundestag on May 31, 2007. The next day, he became a lobbyist. He changed sides from one day to the next, from representative of the people to the shareholder’s representative, without even taking a break in between.
When Wissmann took over as VDA president over a year ago, things were looking better for the climate than for German cars. European Commissioner for the Environment Stavros Dimas wanted to implement an emissions limit of 120 grams of CO2 per kilometer for all new cars by 2012. Manufacturers who didn’t reach these specifications would pay penalties -- high penalties. The goal of 120 grams of CO2 per kilometer is considerably easier for Fiat or Renault than for Daimler or BMW and so it was clear who would primarily pay the price: buyers of German cars.
Wissmann had to do something. He gave interviews, went on talk shows, took part in panel discussions -- that was part of the strategy, to tell the public about the German car manufacturers’ plight. The other part was much less conspicuous: Wissmann had to step into the political ring, in this case Brussels politics.
In the past few months, Wissmann has met with many European Parliament members. He already knew them well -- after all, shortly before he joined the VDA, he was chairman of the Bundestag’s European Union committee. The day after the conversation by the fireside in Brussels, Werner Langen, a member of the European Parliament for the CDU, authored a press release in which he stated that CO2 legislature in the European Parliament has “long been on a realistic path.” In the press release, Langen called for exactly what Wissmann’s VDA wanted -- even some of the wording was identical.
Next stop for Wissmann was Paris. He knew he couldn’t achieve his goal without the French. No really important topic is decided in Europe without France, and so strictly speaking Wissmann had two opponents to overcome: the climate and France.
Again his contacts helped him, this time in Germany, more precisely in the CDU. “Of course I can get an appointment with a federal minister when necessary,” says Wissmann. But that’s not difficult -- after all, any president of the VDA would get a slot in a minister’s schedule. The real question is whether another VDA president would also regularly send text messages to the chancellor -- and get answers back. Angela Merkel doesn’t just answer Wissmann’s messages; she also took care of the agreement with Sarkozy. If Wissmann had personally dictated the compromise between the two himself, it would hardly have come out much differently.
- Part 1: The Power Broker Behind the Franco-German CO2 Deal
- Part 2: Worth Every Cent
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2008
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH