In the Red
WestLB Announces Huge Losses as Investigation Launches
Thursday, 8/30/2007 12:41 PM
The troubled state-backed German bank WestLB reported enormous losses Thursday, a day after public prosecutors announced they were launching an investigation into the bank's top management.
In a statement released Thursday, the Düsseldorf-based bank announced it had made a pre-tax loss of 38 million ($52 million) in the first six months of 2007, compared to a profit of 239 million in the same period a year ago. The losses were caused by bad trades in the bank's proprietary trading business -- the same risky speculation at the center of the investigation. Proprietary trading involves trading in stocks with the bank's own money for its own -- rather than its clients' -- profit.
The bank lost a total of 604 million due to misguided speculation in the first half of 2007. However profits in other areas of proprietary trading meant that the overall loss in the trading division could be limited to 309 million, the bank said.
The poor results come one day after an investigation was launched into top WestLB executives. A spokesman for prosecutors in Düsseldorf said Wednesday that an investigation had begun into seven current and former WestLB executives, including ex-chief executive Thomas Fischer, who stepped down last month after pressure was put on him to resign. Two former traders from the bank are also under investigation. WestLB said Wednesday it wanted the case cleared up as quickly as possible.
The seven executives, who previously comprised the entire management board under Fischer, are suspected of violating German corporate law in connection with massive losses incurred in speculative transactions earlier this year. The executives are accused of not fulfilling their obligation to provide adequate information to the supervisory board about the full extent and riskiness of the trades, which involved speculating on changes in the share prices of companies such as BMW, Volkswagen and the retail giant Metro.
An investigation by Germany's financial services regulator BaFin had earlier revealed that the executive board had known about and tolerated risky trading practices since the beginning of 2007, according to media reports.
A question mark lies over the future of the bank, which is owned mainly by the state of North Rhine-Westphalia and two regional savings banks. The savings banks are in favor of a merger with the Stuttgart-based, state-owned bank Landesbank Baden-Württemberg, which recently announced it was buying another troubled state-owned bank, SachsenLB and has expressed interest in a merger with WestLB. However the state government -- which is keen to get rid of its 38-percent stake in WestLB -- wants to investigate other options.
With an eye to saving jobs in Düsseldorf, state governor Jürgen Rüttgers has proposed a merger between WestLB and the Stadtsparkasse Düsseldorf savings bank, which would give WestLB direct access to private customers. The savings banks are opposed to this idea, wanting to keep the consumer banking business for themselves. In an interview with the German news agency DPA Wednesday, Rüttgers demanded that the savings banks come up with an alternative business model for WestLB. A decision is likely to be made by Sept. 10.
The crisis at WestLB, which was also one of several German banks affected by the recent US subprime mortage crisis, increases pressure for a wave of consolidation among German state-owned banks -- something that WestLB itself appears to view as inevitable. "We will play an active role in the planned strategic realignment of WestLB as part of the consolidation of the German (state-owned banks)," Alexander Stuhlmann, chairman of the managing board of WestLB, said in a statement Thursday.