Steve Sees Everything: Apple Under Fire over Privacy in Germany
Apple has long been considered a model company when it comes to privacy protection. But the US company now plans to serve geo-targeted advertising to its smartphone users using the GPS or WiFi data provided by the device. Privacy experts are up in arms -- in America and Germany.
It was 1984, the year to which George Orwell had dedicated his dark vision of a future in a totalitarian world. There were those who conjured up Orwell's prediction, but soon they discovered that things were not nearly as bad as the author had feared when he wrote "1984" in the late 1940s.
It was in the midst of this creepy atmosphere evocative of Orwell's "1984" that Apple, still a tiny US computer-maker at the time, released an ad that was intended to attract a great deal of attention. In the ad, a group of gray and dull-looking people is sitting in front of a huge screen with an image on it of a dictator giving a speech. Suddenly a young woman runs into the room and smashes a hammer into the screen, which then breaks apart with a loud crash.
The message was clear: The evil dictator was IBM, still the world leader in the computer industry at the time, with its efficient, bland, skin-colored computers. The girl symbolized Apple, freedom and revolution.
That was a long time ago. Now Apple itself is a world power and, more recently, it isn't even clear anymore whether the company still represents good or is now the embodiment of uncontrolled power and the Orwellian urge to keep tabs on people. That, at any rate, is the way they see it at Apple's rival, Google. At a conference in mid-May, a Google executive said that If Google did not act we faced a "Draconian future" -- one in which "one man, one company, one device, one carrier would be our only choice." To reinforce his message, he projected the number "1984" onto the wall.
An Omniscient Data Leviathan
Apple CEO Steve Jobs picked up the gauntlet in early June, when he said: "They decided to compete with us. So they are." It was yet another attempt to continue playing the old game, in which someone else is always portrayed as the bad guy. But it isn't working anymore.
Apple itself is in the process of becoming an omnipresent and omniscient data leviathan, a "Big Brother" that knows or wants to know more and more about its customers -- but reveals almost no information itself.
In the past few days, every Apple customer who has attempted to buy something in the iTunes Music Store or the App Store has been confronted with a window in which he is asked to read and agree to new terms and conditions. In the text, the global corporation requests the customer's consent to Apple knowing where he -- and his iPhone, iPad or MacBook -- happens to be at any given time, and to Apple processing the information and even disclosing it to third parties.
In legal jargon, the message reads: Effective immediately, "Apple and our partners and licensees" may "collect, use and share precise location data, including the real-time geographic location of your Apple computer or device." Apple claims that this geographical data is "collected anonymously in a form that does not personally identify you." But the company does not specify exactly how it intends to ensure that this will be the case.
The move was met with outrage. It was the Los Angeles Times that seized upon the questionable passage, thereby bringing Apple, after Google and Facebook, its first real data privacy scandal. US bloggers promptly dubbed the program "iSpy," and the blog "The Consumerist" has characterized the company's thirst for data as "creepy."
Extremely Sensitive Data
As belated as all the fuss may be, it is nevertheless justified. The one thing that is clear is that the data Apple is gathering and storing is extremely sensitive. Someone who knows a person's exact whereabouts can reach surprisingly precise conclusions about his life. Apple, for its part, might as well forget about its anti-Orwellian image of itself.
To make matters worse, for the first time the company is trying to sell this information on a large scale to advertising customers.
Ironically, it was only in early June that the Apple CEO insisted that his company was very concerned about privacy. Jobs claims the company is particularly worried about the use of geographical location data obtained from smartphones. He even claimed that when it comes to privacy issues, Apple might seem old-fashioned, because of its wary view of things.
Now, as a problem that is not entirely new is finally being recognized, German politicians -- who have been very vocal in their criticism of the privacy policies of Google and Facebook -- are also expressing concern. Justice Minister Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger, a member of the pro-business Free Democratic Party (FDP), says that Apple must "immediately disclose" what data it captures, how long the data is stored and how it is used.
"It must be clear to the users of iPhones and other GPS-enabled devices what information about them is being gathered," says the minister, adding that it would be "inconceivable" if Apple were in fact to create personality or even mobility profiles of its users. "In this case, I feel that it is Apple's obligation to actually implement the transparency so often invoked by Steve Jobs." And then she added: "I expect Apple to provide German privacy groups with access to its databases."
Till Steffen, a Green Party politician and minister of justice for the city-state of Hamburg, also takes a critical view of the issue: "The providers' unclear data privacy rules show, once again, that privacy laws are lagging behind Internet technologies."
- Part 1: Apple Under Fire over Privacy in Germany
- Part 2: Apple Takes on Google Where It Is Most Vulnerable
Stay informed with our free news services:
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2010
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH
Corriere della Sera
MORE FROM SPIEGEL INTERNATIONAL
German PoliticsMerkel's Moves: Power Struggles in Berlin
World War IITruth and Reconciliation: Why the War Still Haunts Europe
EnergyGreen Power: The Future of Energy
European UnionUnited Europe: A Continental Project
Climate ChangeGlobal Warming: Curbing Carbon Before It's Too Late