Bad News from Athens: Greek Budget Figures Complicate Bailout Efforts
The Greek economy is still shrinking -- and will continue to do so through next year, the country's Finance Ministry announced on Monday. In addition to missing its deficit targets, the continued contraction has multiplied doubts as to the wisdom of saving Greece at all.
Greek civil servants, like these blocking the entrance to the Transport Ministry last week, are worried about their futures.
Just last week, international markets were buoyed by hopes that Europe, finally, had decided to throw the kitchen sink at the euro crisis. On Thursday, Germany's parliament seemed to justify those hopes by approving its share of the expanded European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF).
What a difference a weekend makes. On Sunday, Greece announced that its 2011 budget deficit will be 8.5 percent of gross domestic product, well higher than the 7.6 percent it targeted last year as part of its ambitious plan to return to fiscal health. And on Monday, new figures indicate that the country's economy will contract by 2.5 percent in 2012 instead of the hoped for growth of 0.6 percent. Stock markets around the world plunged as a result.
The figures have been made public as officials in Athens struggle to put together a budget for 2012 amid growing doubts that the country will be able to avoid insolvency. The country is also anxiously awaiting a report by officials from the European Union, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund -- a group known as the "troika" -- which will determine whether Athens is eligible for the next, 8 billion payment from the ongoing 110 billion bailout passed in 2010.
In an effort to satisfy austerity demands made by the troika, Greek Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos announced this weekend that 30,000 public sector jobs were to be cut by Christmas. The cuts, Venizelos hopes, will help lower the country's budget deficit to 6.8 percent of GDP in 2012, which is still higher than the 6.5 percent originally envisioned. He also says that the move will return the budget to surplus status once debt-service payments are factored out.
"The 2012 budget completes an intense and difficult effort of fiscal adjustment, reaching a primary surplus of 3.2 billion in 2012 from a primary deficit of 24 billion in 2009," he said in a statement.
The new numbers are particularly ominous given that European Union leaders, when they initially agreed in July to a second, 109 billion bailout package for Greece, assumed a growth rate of 0.6 percent. With the recession now set to continue for at least another year, the country will likely need significantly more funding. Germany's parliament is set to vote on that bailout package this month.
In addition, European banks, which agreed in July to a 21 percent writedown in the value of their Greek debt holdings, may end up suffering much larger losses. "Greece is bankrupt," said Michael Fuchs, deputy floor leader in parliament for Merkel's Christian Democrats, in comments to the daily Rheinische Post. "Probably there is no other way for us other than to accept at least a 50 percent haircut on its debt."
Deutsche Bank head Josef Ackermann, however, warned against revisiting the voluntary agreement. "If we reopen the voluntary accord of July 21, we will not only lose precious time, but quite possibly also private-sector support," Ackermann told the Greek daily Kathimerini.
Last week, markets rose on hopes that Europe was preparing to vastly expand the EFSF beyond the 440 billion it has already committed to. Alternately, there was talk of "leveraging" the fund by using its current assets as collateral to borrow up to 2 trillion. Several denials from Germany in particular would seem to have put a damper on such hopes. But according to Olli Rehn, Europe's commissioner for economics and monetary affairs, finance ministers meeting on Monday in Brussels are set to discuss ways to leverage the fund, suggesting that Germany's "nein" has not been unconditional.
Europe, Rehn said on Monday, faced a three-pronged challenge of "stalling growth, stressed sovereigns and still vulnerable banks." Euro-zone ministers were not expected to make any decisions on Monday.
A Complete Standstill
Still, many remain convinced that Europe needs to take drastic action to get its debt crisis under control. Austan Goolsbee, the chairman of Barack Obama's Council of Economic Advisors who recently resigned, told SPIEGEL in an interview that Europe needed to focus on rapidly recapitalizing European banks to avoid a deep financial crisis once Greece defaults. "If Europe does not deal with the problem of undercapitalized banks, it could easily blow up and turn into another worldwide conflagration," he said.
Magnifying the problem are indications that the euro-zone economy is already suffering with a steep drop in export demand hitting several economies hard. According to the Manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index, a survey carried out by Markit of euro-zone purchasing managers and an important measure of factory activity, manufacturing shrank last month at a pace not seen since the middle of 2009. Germany too has seen a significant slowdown with manufacturing growth having all but come to a complete standstill.
cgh -- with wire reports
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2011
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH