World from Berlin: Cyprus Chaos 'Doesn't Inspire Hope for EU Future'
With Cyprus racing to install capital controls before re-opening its banks on Thursday, German media commentators say the island has only itself to blame for its plight. They also warn though that the tough bailout terms are a fresh sign of waning solidarity among euro-zone member states.
Banks in Cyprus will remain closed until Thursday to prevent a run on deposits in the wake of the bailout deal reached on Sunday night that imposes a major levy on big depositors, many of them Russian, and shuts down the second-largest bank, Cyprus Popular, also known as Laiki.
Meanwhile, even though the banks have been closed since March 16, large amounts of money have been withdrawn from them, according to Reuters. The news agency quoted an EU source saying the Central Bank of Cyprus had requested more banknotes from the European Central Bank than were warranted in terms of the withdrawals it was reporting to the ECB.
The scale of the outflow isn't known. Money has been moved out in various ways. Transfers for trade in humanitarian products, medicines and jet fuel remain allowed, for example. In addition, Laiki and Bank of Cyprus have units in London which remained open throughout last week and they placed no limits on withdrawals, according to Reuters. Bank of Cyprus also owns 80 percent of Russia's Uniastrum Bank, which put no restrictions on withdrawals in Russia.
The terms of the bailout have predictably angered Russia, and Germany is once again being vilified for taking a hard line. German media commentators say that while Cyprus brought its problems on itself, the rescue reveals an erosion of solidarity among euro-zone members after three years of crisis. The messy wrangling that preceded the bailout has done lasting damage to the EU, they add.
Conservative Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung writes:
"The Cypriots may see themselves as victims, but their European partners aren't to blame for the mess. The case of Cyprus shows how rife alienation and anger are among Europeans: Many in the crisis-hit nations are blaming their plight not on their own corrupt elites or bad governance but on supposedly unsympathetic EU governments, meaning the supposedly neo-hegemonial Germans. The donor countries in turn feel they are the victims of blackmail who are rewarded for their help with insults. At the start of the fourth year of the debt and euro crisis, one can't help but register that trust and empathy have been eroded along the way. It doesn't inspire hope for the future of the EU."
Center-left Süddeutsche Zeitung writes:
"This drastic infringement of property rights was possible due to the unique constellation in Cyprus: Cyprus is the third-smallest country of the European Union, so its political weight isn't very relevant. Cyprus set up a dubious business model that attracted dubious people; they're now being punished, so the burden isn't necessarily hitting the wrong people. The expropriation satisfied the sense of justice of most Germans, and not just them."
"Thirdly, a remarkably poor set of Cypriot politicians refused to see reason for much too long, and in the last week displayed an unpleasant gambling mentality. Anyone who manages in just four days to alienate the entire euro zone, discredit the Euro Group chief, tries to involve Russia in a circumventing maneuver and welds together the German government and opposition in an election year has failed to understand a few basic rules on transparency and policymaking in Europe."
"In this unique combination, Cyprus will remain a unique case. But Europe has changed a lot as a result of this rescue drama. The readiness to show solidarity is eroding by the minute. The euro zone has long since stopped being a brotherhood for increasing prosperity and mutual stability. It has transformed itself into a school of gladiators in which everyone fights for his own advantage and his survival."
Conservative Die Welt writes:
"The solution for Nicosia is no blueprint for dealing with other bank crises. Authorities wouldn't dare to repeat such a procedure in Italy or Spain. If a bank has obtained most of its money from other banks or financial institutions, a radical cut becomes far more complicated because the consequences would eat through the entire financial system. The collapse of Lehman Brothers made this dramatically clear."
"While the international impact of the Cypriot bank restructuring is likely to remain limited, the island nation itself will struggle. Not just rich foreigners but many Cypriot companies will lose a large part of their deposits -- which will inflict major damage on the country's economy."
"The Cypriot compromise is a big experiment. Its outcome will determine how Europe tackles future crises. And whether taxpayers will in future be able to avoid always having to foot the bill for troubled banks."
Left-wing daily Die Tageszeitung writes:
"The case of Cyprus will mean once again that billions of euros will be shifted around. Whenever there's a minor problem, investors in Portugal, Italy or Spain will hurriedly transfer their money to Germany or the Netherlands. They will all try to turn their Spanish or Italian euros into German or Dutch euros. The monetary union may still exist, but it is history nonetheless. Officially we may still have one euro, but in effect we've had 17 different euros for a long time now."
Mass circulation Bild writes:
"The washing machine for illegal Russian money has been switched off! And the Kremlin is fuming. When Cyprus needed savings, Russia didn't lift a finger. Now it's throwing dirt at the rescuers. For Russia's billionaires, Cyprus was a euro colony where they could increase their wealth. It's only fair that they and not the small savers have to pay a high price for rescuing Cyprus."
Left-wing daily Berliner Zeitung writes:
"The European Union too has been damaged. People will remember the rudeness of the German finance minister, who was more focused on public sentiment in Germany than on the welfare of the community. And the politicians have made one thing clear to all investors and savers inside and outside the currency union: If you invest your money in the euro zone, you take on enormous political risks in addition to economic ones. This loss of confidence will have lasting impact, in the crisis-hit nations and far beyond Europe's borders."
-- David Crossland
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH