SWIFT Suspension? EU Parliament Furious about NSA Bank Spying

By in Brussels

Members of the European Parliament are furious with US spying. Zoom
REUTERS

Members of the European Parliament are furious with US spying.

Revelations the US is spying on international bank transfers have angered European parliamentarians. Some are calling for the suspension of the SWIFT deal between the EU and US. "Washington must make clear where it stands," says one.

The recent revelations regarding the degree to which the US intelligence agency NSA monitors bank data in the European Union has infuriated many in Europe. "Now that we know what we have long been suspecting, we have to protest loudly and clearly," Jan Philipp Albrecht, a legal expert for the Green Party in the European Parliament, told SPIEGEL ONLINE. He is demanding a suspension of the SWIFT agreement, which governs the transfer of some bank data from the EU to anti-terror authorities in the United States.

On Monday, SPIEGEL reported that the NSA monitors a significant share of international money transfers, including bank and credit card transactions. The information comes from documents in the possession of whistleblower Edward Snowden that SPIEGEL has been able to see. "Follow the Money" is the name of the NSA branch that handles the surveillance. Information obtained by "Follow the Money" then flows into a financial database known as Tracfin. In 2011, Tracfin had 180 million datasets -- 84 percent of which are comprised of credit card data.

But data from the SWIFT network, headquartered in Brussels, also ends up on Tracfin. SWIFT, which handles international transfers among thousands of banks, is identified by the NSA as a "target" according to the Snowden documents. They also show that the NSA monitors SWIFT on several different levels, with the NSA department for "tailored access operations" also being involved. Among other methods, the documents note that the NSA has the ability to read "SWIFT printer traffic from numerous banks."

'The Clear Standard'

European Parliament President Martin Schulz also demanded consequences. "European data protection regulations have to be the clear standard in dealings with the Americans," he told SPIEGEL ONLINE. He said that simply abandoning the SWIFT agreement would be ineffective without an alternative for handling important international banking transactions. But the US government, he added, must live up to its obligations regarding openness with Europe.

Manfred Weber, a German conservative in the European Parliament, echoed the demand. "Washington must make it clear where it stands." He said that the focus should be placed on consumer protection. "That would make companies and politicians in America listen up," Weber said in comments made in Washington.

The reactions have been intense in part because the European Parliament flexed its muscles in 2010 when a first draft of the SWIFT agreement came up for a vote. The lawmaking body rejected the treaty before ultimately passing a new version with strengthened data protection language.

Fulfilling the regulations has proven difficult. After a long period of silence, European Commissioner for Home Affairs Cecilia Malmström has also since weighed in, demanding clarity from the US. But Social Democrats, Liberals, Greens and leftists in the European Parliament want more. They have demanded the suspension of the SWIFT deal between the US and the EU. "The Americans are apparently breaking into the system. We are being played for fools and spied on without limits," said liberal European parliamentarian Sophie in 't Veld.

Shedding Light

A suspension of the data protection deal would be a first in trans-Atlantic affairs -- and it is also unlikely. Even in the event of a parliamentary majority, the European Council would likewise have to agree.

"But we parliamentarians have to show clearly where we stand," says Albrecht. "The NSA activities have been known now for 14 weeks, and one still can't see any real effort by EU governments or by the US to shed light on the situation."

James Clapper, director of US national intelligence, said in the Washington Post earlier this week that the NSA collects financial information to provide "the US and our allies early warning of international financial crises which could negatively impact the global economy."

But even in the US, a spirited debate is underway over the limits of the surveillance state. The most recent to weigh in was former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld in his interview with SPIEGEL published earlier this week. "Should people be concerned about their privacy? You bet," he said. "Nobody wants to think that everything they do or say is under surveillance."

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
15 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. Excelent choice of topic, again!
hvdj101 09/18/2013
I have seen der Spiegel courageously acknowledging gangstalking and microwave weapons when no one did. Good work der Spiegel!
2. Fools of a Sort
Jim in MD 09/18/2013
The EU should suspend the SWIFT agreement and learn to live on its own. Europe really should get out of NATO and form its own defense too. The curious thing about these revelations of the NSA is that they do not reveal the USA using Europe for its own profit. They do demonstrate that Europe has an unhealthy dependence on the USA for security, finances, foreign policy and trade. It is time for Europeans to give up conspiracy theories and really take control of their own lives. It will involve taking responsibilities long given to the USA and spending money on defense and world affairs that used to go to social welfare. Everyone will have to adjust.
3. optional
danm 09/18/2013
The debate in the USA is tempered by the leftwing attack dogs in the press. Anyone who disagrees with Obama on anything including the NSA spy scandal is automatically characterized as a reactionary, knuckle dragging, racist neanderthal. Seriously, the current day leftwing hate machine, euphamistically called the press, makes Roy Cohen look like Walt Disney.
4. An empty European Parlement
herman855 09/18/2013
Where were the Members of the European Parlement. This enormous empty space illustrates why the people have lost their trust in those so-called European Parlementarians whom in fact exist only on the payrolls but not in REALTIME. Indeed discouraging 'Spokes' they should be named. In fact its deeply sad to witness this kind of 'just for the money democracy'. With sincere sadness. Herman Roeffen
5. Old and Irrelevant News by Snowden's Boring Stuff Again!
cdestache 09/18/2013
If foreign banks don't hold U.S. Currency Reserves, then U.S. wouldn't care a dime about it! The Fed Reserves controlling money supplies, for most cases, controlling its dollars' values and flowing of cash between banks for "tax purposes" in most cases. They don't care much about "terrorism" thing but it's "more" about rich people hiding taxes from them. 400 richest Americans have 2 trillion dollars net worth right now, like The American Gov't care bout little stinky banks somewhere in Portugal or Hong Kong! EU beating a dead horse! U.S. economy is getting better, in couple years, the Americans no longer depend on oil imports... which is the most heavy burden $$$ of trade deficits... but it'll be over soon!
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Europe section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH




Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: Spying on Smartphones

Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: Art at Berlin's Teufelsberg Spy Station

European Partners
Facebook
Twitter