Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.

Opinion: Europe's Juncker Bond


Jean-Claude Juncker on Germany: 'Very insulting to others.' Zoom

Jean-Claude Juncker on Germany: 'Very insulting to others.'

Jean-Claude Juncker vehemently criticized German-imposed austerity measures during the euro crisis. By doing so, he gained support in a number of countries -- especially those which would like to see the common currency zone degraded into a debt union.

Let's be clear: Jean-Claude Juncker is no friend of Germany. More to the point, the man is only friendly to the Germans so long as they are willing to cover the debts of their neighbors without grumbling too loudly. But as soon as Berlin suggests that other countries first take a look at their own spending before asking for German help, Mr. Juncker becomes indignant. Those well-behaved Germans, who he has praised in the past for doing so much for unity on the Continent under Helmut Kohl, quickly become barbarians in his eyes, unwilling to learn anything from the past.

Here are a handful of examples. During the peak of the euro crisis, there came a point when German parliament didn't immediately rubber stamp a part of some bailout package, preferring to take its time to clarify some details. An indignant Juncker railed: "Part of the problem is acting as if Germany is the only virtuous country in the world, as if Germany is having to foot the bill for all the other countries. That's very insulting to the others." When Germany insisted that countries requiring aid commit to stricter budget discipline, he stated: "Why does Germany bestow itself the luxury of constantly deciding domestic policy for others when it comes to the issue of the euro? Why does Germany treat the euro zone as if it were some kind of franchise in its own chain?" When Germany rejected the idea of euro bonds, he had this to say: "This method of erecting taboo areas in Europe and not even considering the ideas proposed by other people is a very un-European way of taking care of European business. Germany's thinking is a bit simplistic."

Disregarding the Electorate

Word has it that Jean-Claude Juncker now wants to become European Commission president. The only person at the moment who has the power to stand between him and this goal is the German chancellor. On the flip side, support for the former Luxembourg prime minister is greatest in places that have the most to gain from his rise. So it's worth recalling just how this man thinks -- a man who is being peddled as the only obvious candidate by interested parties.

Juncker is basing his claim on the results of the European election, which this time was allegedly not only about voting to determine the distribution of seats in the European Parliament, but also the nomination for the far more important post of the European Commission president. The deception started at the very beginning. And it was Juncker, of the conservative Christian Democrats, and his co-candidate Martin Schulz, of the center-left Social Democrats, who unleashed this illusion that the election would be about more than filling the seats in parliament. They did so to position themselves for more powerful offices. The fact that this fiction is now being maintained doesn't make it any less of a fiction.

What in most places would be called a shell game is called "democracy" in Brussels. First you pull the wool over the eyes of the people by making them think they can vote for something over which, in fact, the leaders of the EU member states have the power of determination. And when these leaders finally insist on their right to ignore these self-nominated candidates, the talk is suddenly of disregard for the electorate.

Turning a Currency Union into a Debt Union

The fact that no one has stepped up to reel off a list of qualifications that would make a convincing case for recommending Juncker for the post is most telling. His only real achievement is the fact that he managed to hold on to power for 18 years in a country whose business model is based on providing safe harbor to tax evaders from neighboring countries. Indeed, this is a man who knows a thing or two about living off of other peoples' money. It remains one of the great mysteries of this European business how the left-leaning Social Democrats of all parties could stand behind a man who is social only in an extremely broad sense.

Juncker is part of a faction on the Continent who dream of transforming Europe's currency union into a debt union. This is good news for those who, for some time now, have felt that Europe has gotten carried away with its austerity measures. We shouldn't be fooled. When Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi now offers the prospect of support for Juncker, what we are seeing is really part of a larger offensive against Berlin's so-called austerity diktat. Renzi doesn't even bother to hide this, either, demanding that the EU must finally abandon its austerity policies. Renzi's position seems to be: If Juncker can help achieve that goal, then he must be the right candidate.

Those still capable of distinguishing between Italian and German interests can only hope that the German chancellor will for once listen to the British and send Juncker packing with a resounding "nein". Even if the rest of the world is pointing fingers at David Cameron right now, that doesn't mean the English prime minister is wrong. On the contrary: In the case of the European Commission, we would be well advised to close ranks with London rather than with Rome and Luxembourg.

Discuss this issue with other readers!
19 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. Juncker represents failure
ulyssesreturns 06/05/2014
Finally someone writing here who can see past the European Union fog and recognise Junker for what he is - an anti-democratic ineptocrat who will take the EU backwards hen it needs to reform or die. At a time when the lunatics in Brussels are considering admitting Albania (of all countries) and the ECB has set negative interest rates, the election of a man who has no describable talents is threatening to ruin the relationship between the two great powers of Europe. If Merkel betrays Cameron and the UK in this, she will never be forgiven and we will head for the exit sooner rather than later, and then who will Germany have to help them pay for the mess left behind?
2. Balance
aviator9152 06/05/2014
Sir, Thank you for this article. I thought your report about Cameron's position with regard to Juncker biased and unfair. What was seen as a threat or as blackmail was simply Cameron telling the truth from a British perspective. The appointment of Juncker, a self avowed federalist, with a decidedly "shady" background would harden anti EU attitudes in the UK. From my perspective I didn't vote for any President in this election, I voted for my British representative to the EU parliament nothing more, and for Juncker, Schultz or whoever to try presume that this was in any way a presidential election is simply wrong. i respectfully suggest that probably less than 1 in 10 people knew the name "Juncker before this affair.
3. Juncker
oleengholm 06/05/2014
The recent EU election demonstrated that most voters thought it was no use voting. With Juncker at the rudder this will be confirmed. The EU functions best without the electorate.
4. A consistent editorial stance ?
idbeckett 06/05/2014
Perhaps Carsten Volkery (http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/cameron-risks-losing-merkel-as-ally-in-eu-feud-a-973389.html ) and Jan Fleischhauer (http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/opinion-why-germany-should-say-no-to-juncker-a-973540.html ) should interview each other. I suspect it would be a fascinating piece. It seems that even Der Spiegel has difficulties in relation to the great Juncker yes or no debate.
5. It is time this man goes!
Inglenda2 06/05/2014
This is typical of the EU, Jean-Claude Juncker now wants to become European Commission president, so that nobody else has the chance to clear up the mess he has made of Europe.
Show all comments
    Page 1    

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH

Jan Fleischhauer
  • Dagmar Morath
    Jan Fleischhauer is a longtime editor and reporter at DER SPIEGEL. After the fall of the Berlin Wall, he reported for the magazine from Leipzig and later in Berlin and New York, where he served as the magazine's economics correspondent. The author of several books on German politics, Fleischhauer has been based in our Berlin bureau since 2005. He pens SPIEGEL ONLINE's weekly conservative political column.
  • Jan Fleischhauer on Facebook
  • Jan Fleischhauer on Twitter

International Newsletter
Sign up for our newsletter -- and get the very best of SPIEGEL in English sent to your email inbox twice weekly.