Terror in Europe The Need to Protect Our Freedom

What lessons can be drawn from the attacks in Paris? Simple answers will do little to help at the moment. What is needed is a new, Europe-wide security debate.

A Commentary by

People light candles during a vigil in Kathmandu following the deadly terrorist attacks in Paris.
REUTERS

People light candles during a vigil in Kathmandu following the deadly terrorist attacks in Paris.


The events in Paris, the shaky mobile phone videos of the shootout in the Bataclan theater, the explosions during the football match between the French and German national teams in Stade de France have shaken the world. Conversations in homes and workplaces, among friends and acquaintances, about the scenes that unfolded Friday night and into Saturday morning have shifted from disbelief to disgust, and from mourning to uncertainty. Was this an attack against all of us and our way of life?

Once again we are experiencing moments like the one that followed Sept. 11 or the attacks on London and Madrid -- moments in which we are forced to remind ourselves our true values: An open, democratic society defined by pluralism, equal rights and freedom of expression, belief in the rule of law, respect for our fellow people and the protection of life.

In such moments, it isn't helpful when harebrains on the Web, in some media and within Germany's own conservative Christian Social Union (CSU), the Bavarian sister party to Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats, use the terrorist attacks in Paris as an instrument to agitate against the influx of refugees to Germany and to stoke hostilities against them. By doing so they do more to harm free society than to help it. Placing thousands of innocent refugees in the same context as the Paris murderers is disgraceful.

Photo Gallery

15  Photos
Photo Gallery: Anger and Sadness in Paris
On Saturday, one of the more outspoken voices against refugees in the CSU, Bavarian Finance Minister Markus Söder, tweeted that the Paris attacks change "everything. We cannot allow illegal and uncontrolled immigration."

A Time for Nuance and Calm

Particularly in times of chaos and uncertainty, it is more important than ever to view and analyze events in a nuanced manner and to remain calm despite feelings of dismay that are, of course, understandable.

Yes, the terrible images coming out of Paris have shocked us, in no small part because they are pictures that are not typically part of our free society. For us as Europeans, it is self-evident that streets, stadiums, restaurants and concert halls are safe places. This fundamental trust is the foundation of our public life. In Paris, this foundation has been shaken. It is only natural that people begin doubting the efficacy of our security.

And therein lies the long-term danger. If we allow ourselves to limit the scope of our public life, then the terrorists will not only have achieved their short-term goal of murdering and spreading chaos, but also their long-term goal to damaging the foundations of our public life. We cannot allow this to happen.

The Paris attacks underscore the fact that we need a new security debate in Europe. But this debate shouldn't begin and end with the invocation of the NATO mutual defense clause, with the rhetoric of a "world war" or with giant headlines on front pages. The louder the war cries, the bleaker the outlook will be. This is a time for keeping cool. We need to examine things very carefully and ask some tough questions.

A Need to Reflect

How is it possible that Paris could be attacked twice in one year by terrorist groups? What went wrong with the French security apparatus? What lessons can we draw from this -- in France, but also in Germany and other European countries? Have we only been spared of attacks and dozens of deaths in Germany because we haven't dispatched any fighter jets to Syria, or do our intelligence services and police somehow work more effectively? If the latter is true, then how can European countries work together in order to provide better support to improve security? Which instruments are needed to prevent further attacks without damaging public life? And, yes, also: How can we quickly and more intelligently organize the influx and registration of refugees while at the same time making it possible to identify threats among the vast majority that is simply looking for refuge.

It appears that trans-national terrorist structures took shape right in the middle of Europe. If it is proven that the some preparations for the Paris attacks took place in Belgium and that they were orchestrated by strategists with the Islamic State, then it is true that all of us in Europe are threatened by this terror. But it will not be possible to find the correct response in a matter of just a few hours or days. And it also won't be a solution that can be described in a few short sentences.

About the Author
Christian Bruch/ DER SPIEGEL
Florian Harms is the editor in chief of SPIEGEL ONLINE.

E-Mail: Florian_Harms@spiegel.de

Article...


Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
14 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
portuguesepov 11/16/2015
1. Will the grown-ups in Germany please stand up ?
If all 27 Gov's in Europe stopped picking up the phone, it's not because they are Islamophobes, Germany. The problem is that your Chanceler wants to have her cake and eat it. You can't be a stickler for the rules ,AND unilaterally abolish them. Nobody in Europe is willing to follow you on this. Either Dublin , or you're on your own. Look on the bright side, Germany . You have finally achieved true gender equality, by having extremely incompetent women in high responsabilty positions. Congratulations. Can we have Adenauer or Kohl back ?
j_mclennan_99 11/16/2015
2. My prediction
I predict the New Germany sits on the sidelines being smugly ethical and giving pious lectures. The Old Germany looked for dominance the old fashioned way; the New Germany is the world capital of smug, holier than thou sanctimony. The New Germany will be friendless when it is in need of friends. For the sake of all and for the sake of yourselves - find the balance! You talk about European solidarity but when it comes down to it Germany can be relied on to dump a friend in need.
Inglenda2 11/17/2015
3. A war on human iniquity?
As they sing in Germany, (Die Gedanken sind frei)! So how can you deal with a mental condition by the use of armed force? Wars cause deaths and can so temporally remove symptoms of human radicalism. What they cannot do, as we can learn from the history of Europe, is cure thwarted minds. Despite WW2 and all calls for intelligent perception and approach, towards world problems, we still have countries which have nationalist or communist governments. The same applies to religious fanaticism, which can be observed within at least two of the oldest religions known. Even under the so-called friendly countries, it can be an offence, which incurs execution, to convert to Christianity. Before charging into conflicts abroad, which often just worsen the conditions under which the normal citizens are forced to live, education at home is often failing. In Europe alone, there are hundreds of homes, in which husbands have sticks, with which they truly believe they have the right, or duty, to beat wives for being disobedient. We must decide ourselves, what is more important, the equality of men and women, or the freedom of religions. The later of which often allow not only oppression of others, but also the mutilation of children. The sadness of what has happened in France should not encourage us to point fingers at others, before we have cleaned up our own doorstep.
Blueberry 11/17/2015
4. Merkel
Merkel and the treacherous Federal Gov are so stupid and don't realise they are destroying Germany and Europe and are partly to blame for events in Paris
hghcape 11/17/2015
5. Border Security
Short of dismissing the Schengen rules, the EU should establish tight border controls at the EU entry borders staffed with trained professionals from each EU country and funded through the EU with a special fund. The Americans locked their airports and access to airplanes after 9/11. The world followed. Border controls like this t would be a similar inconvenience but doable and likely agreeable to most and foremost a balanced approach to privacy concerns.
Show all comments
Page 1

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2015
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH


Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.