The Poverty Lie: How Europe's Crisis Countries Hide their Wealth

By SPIEGEL Staff

Photo Gallery: Who Should Cover Debts in the Euro Crisis? Photos
AP

Part 3: A Culture of Shirking Taxes

But even people who are considered affluent by the numbers do not consider themselves rich. They too feel that they are victims of the crisis, and they are worse off today than in the past. But does this mean they cannot be expected to bear a greater burden to save their country?

Take, for example, Dimitris, a resident of Crete (not his real name). He's a post office employee, his wife works in university administration, and both have been public servants for decades, which gives them secure incomes and small pension claims, although those benefits have been cut substantially since the debt crisis hit Greece.

Dimitris, his wife Maria and their two teenage sons live in a condominium in the administrative capital Heraklion. They also own a building in the southern part of the island with a small owner's apartment and 12 guest rooms that are rented out, a small but clean building with a view of the water, directly on the beach. The mother lives in a small house that she owns in the nearby village. The road to the village passes Dimitris's olive groves and fields of orange trees.

Now that he is close to retirement, Dimitris devotes most of his time -- including his working hours -- to the trees, which he grows organically. Dimitris and Maria are not doing well, subjectively at least. "Our costs are too high," he complains, after maneuvering one of his three cars into a parking space at the beach. "Just imagine. Now we have to pay taxes on all three properties and the cars."

The world doesn't make sense to Dimitris anymore. "Twenty-five percent," he says. He now loses a quarter of his earnings to taxes. "I don't know how I'll manage it."

In the past, life for Greek civil servants was often a different one. Their income taxes were taken directly out of their wages, but the tax authorities could traditionally be easily circumvented when it came to side earnings from things like olive oil sales or renting rooms to tourists.

Lois Labrianidis, a 59-year-old economist and professor at the University of Macedonia in the northern Greek city of Thessaloniki, attributes the lack of acceptance of tax payments and a tax liability to a sort of north-south gradient in the general consciousness, as well as an absence of public spirit. "We lack the parameters," he says. He is referring, for example, to the recognition that paying taxes to the government also enhance a citizen's personal social security and provisions for old age.

Southern Europe's Shadow Economies

Southern Europeans in a number of countries have traditionally paid no taxes on a good share of their income, which is one reason households with far smaller incomes have been able to accumulate substantially larger assets than German households.

Estimates by Friedrich Schneider, an economist in the Austrian city of Linz, reveal how horrifying the scope of the shadow economy is in the crisis-ridden countries of the euro zone. Among all the countries in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain occupy the first four positions in the applicable negative ranking.

On the Iberian Peninsula and in Italy, the hidden economy makes up 20 percent of GDP, compared with almost 25 percent in Greece. By comparison, it only constitutes about 13 percent in Germany, and significantly less than 10 percent in other euro countries, like Austria and the Netherlands.

The greater the importance of moonlighting, the lower the tax revenues. The shadow economy deprives Spain, Italy and other countries of dozens of billions of euros in tax revenue each year, and has been doing so for decades.

Schneider's figures also show that in Greece, Spain and Portugal, the shadow economy plays an even greater role today than it did in the late 1980s. The scope of the shadow economy has declined in Italy, but only slightly. In other words, if attitudes toward taxation in Southern Europe were just as good as they are in the north, the debt-ridden countries would have solved their budget problems long ago.

All problems aside, Lars Feld, a member of the German Council of Economic Experts, also sees the ECB figures as good news. "They show that Germany, with its tough conditions for the euro bailout funds, is in the right."

After all, the debt-ridden countries are only eligible for the billions from bailout funds if they satisfy certain conditions in return. In addition to spending cuts and tax increases, they generally include the obligation to actually collect taxes. If tax laws not only appear on paper, but are also enforced, then "even Greece will be able to set aside doubts concerning the sustainability of its debts," says Feld.

Countries More Prosperous than Previously Thought

Despite the drawbacks and qualifications of the ECB's wealth figures, one realization remains: The countries of the south are far more prosperous than previously supposed.

For these countries' governments and the politicians in the partner countries dealing with bailouts, this can only lead to one conclusion: There is still plenty to be had. Cash-strapped countries that have already taken advantage of aid from the bailout funds should be required to increase their own contribution even further.

In fact, the ailing economies have already begun increasing taxes on their citizens, in some cases substantially. In this context, many governments are also taking aim at assets.

Last year, for example, Spain reintroduced a wealth tax that had been abolished five years earlier. It doesn't generate much in revenues, in fact, less than €1 billion. This is because of generous exemptions that can reach €1 million on properties used as primary residences.

The Socialist government in France introduced a special tax on assets last year, which generated €2.3 billion in revenues. The Greek government plans to tax the rich to an even greater extent. After the government drastically increased revenue goals for the wealth tax last year, it now expects revenues to increase from €1.2 billion to €2.7 billion.

The Fight against Tax Evaders

Economist Labrianidis also favors requiring the wealthy to play a stronger role in repaying the government debt. "The biggest problem is tax evasion and tax flight. And I'm not talking about the kiosk owner who doesn't give you a receipt for a pack of cigarettes," says the professor. He is referring to "the very rich," and he is calling for political will and a "wealth registry." Still, Labrianidis sees "no steps being taken in this direction. There is no political will to chase capital."

The average wealth of Greek households may seem high, but the country ranks near the bottom in Europe in terms of tax revenues. In 2011, tax revenues, including social security contributions, amounted to 35 percent of GDP, compared with an EU average of 40 percent.

Greek authorities are also making very little headway in their fight against tax evasion. Lists exist of delinquent doctors, wealthy people unwilling to pay their taxes and tax fugitives in Switzerland. There are also lists of undeclared swimming pools (which are subject to a tax) and proud owners of luxury yachts whose incomes are barely large enough to pay taxes. But the tax collectors continue to come up short. Last year, tax authorities were expected to drum up €2 billion in back taxes to help pay off the country's debt, at least under the conditions imposed by the troika consisting of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the ECB and the European Commission. The actual figure was barely €1.1 billion.

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
15 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. Poor in mind as well as in substance
Inglenda2 04/17/2013
Most of Germany’s difficulties are home-made, especially those in the international field of political finances. Thanks to a whole series of governments, whose members receive such a high income that they have no realisation of normal people’s everyday problems, the value of money has become nothing more for them than a statistical entity. The same politicians who are so fond of explaining, to the less wealthy, how little is needed in order to lead a dignified life, show no restraint whatsoever, when helping themselves and others (for example banks and foreign governments), to taxpayers’ money. Germany could be the richest country in continental Europe, instead, not only the State is in debt, but also the majority of citizens are less wealthy than those of neighbouring countries. The main reason for this completely unnecessary situation is the futile attempt to buy the friendship of other nations. Friends –and this was clearly described in the bible story of the lost son – cannot be bought! Another is the military interference in countries which have never been a danger to Germany. The economical recovery (often called a wonder), which the country experienced following WW2, was largely due to the fact that no armed forces were needed for overseas duties. These, as can been seen in the case of Great Britain, are always an enormous strain for any national economy. To place prestige policies before the wellbeing of ones own electorate, may be quite common in European governments, but it is not only asinine, it is downright dishonest. Democratic governments, (by the people, through the people, for the people,), are there to represent the those who voted them into power, not for their own selfish aspirations. It would therefore seem, that the political parties in Germany have never really understood what true democracy means. Accordingly, the country is not only poor from an economic point of view, but also in its social and moral standing.
2. poverty in Europewho's the fool?
franzosemc 04/18/2013
Read W Münchau article http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/67f9afde-a2c5-11e2-bd45-00144feabdc0,Authorised=false.html?_i_location=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ft.com%2Fcms%2Fs%2F0%2F67f9afde-a2c5-11e2-bd45-00144feabdc0.html&_i_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fmgptpt.wordpress.com%2F2013%2F04%2F14%2Fwolfgang-mnchau-the-riddle-of-europes-single-currency-with-many-values%2F#axzz2QTLk9vHT and Bloomberg http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-04-10/germans-are-poorest-in-the-euro-area-really-.html and http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/eurocrisispress/2013/04/07/selective-truths-and-spanish-riches-the-bundesbanks-study-on-household-wealth-2/
3. Euro-shafted
tnt_ynot 04/18/2013
The Prussians have been duped, deceived, outright conned and are Teutonically shocked to discover they are relatively poverty stricken. Germany’s decent, hardworking and proud citizenry have suddenly been awakened from a comforting illusion only to be confronted with a terrifying nightmare. The vaunted nation with its world champion export machine that filled fleets of freighters with sought after, expensive, industrial pearls labeled “Made in Germany” and for four long years has been bankrolling an ever growing number of down on their luck Club Med brethren now realize they have been robberly hoodwinked. They have, so-to-speak been Euro-shafted. http://euro-meltdown.blogspot.de/
4. A very unbalanced article
ZeLuiz 04/19/2013
This article focuses on accumulated wealth rather than on income. Southern Europeans have much smaller incomes than Germans - in Portugal, for instance, the minimum wage is 485,00 € a month and a qualified worker can earn as little as 600,00 €. If we tend to own more property than Germans, it is partly because we save more (we don't enjoy foreign holidays three times a year, for instance), because an almost inexistent renting market for habitation has forced us to buy (at the beginning of my married life, my whole salary went to our mortgage and we lived on my wife's salary), because a higher proportion of women have full-time jobs than in Germany and because so many of us emigrate and buy property when we came back (the second flat we bought was paid with money I earned in Switzerland). Portugal is the most unequal country in the Eurozone. I would be more than happy to see my wealthier compatriots pay their fair share of taxes, like I do. But our ideologically driven, oligarchy-friendly government doesn't even try - and has the full support of the European Commission, the IMF and the ECB in its choice of beggaring the hard-working, tax-paying citizens instead.
5.
nlefk83 04/19/2013
As a fellow Greek citizen, I wonder why Spiegel is indulging in all this filthy anti-southern country propaganda and where they get these numbers from. I am from a normal, middle-class family, fairly educated and currently working in one of UK's large organisations. This is just to put my social standing into context and assure you that within my social circle that consists of fairly well educated people as well, there may exist only a couple of people whose assets actually reach those levels. You can only imagine how the large, less well-off majority fairs. In fact, most young people in Greece, live in their parents house until they're 35 because they can't afford to live on their own or start their own family. Not to mention taking holidays abroad twice per year, as many German families do. I wonder how Spiegel can so shamelessly factor these numbers and exploit statistics to lie. So, what it effectively tells us that the average (not median, if you know what I mean) assets of the 600k Cypriot population is larger than the average of an almost 150-fold German population, not taking into account the effect of outliers or anything that scientifically makes sense. Even when we disregard this, Spiegel effectively says that Germany made German families poor to get an economic advantage and now everyone has to be poor because German citizens have acted like sheep. Finally - and this is the most important thing - they say nothing about how Germany is actually benefiting from the whole 'bailout' thing because it borrows money with low interest and it lends it to southern countries with high interest. This money is not donated and Germany is not a charitable organization, so stop whining and if you think it's in your advantage to not lend money on interest, don't. We don't even want to be on this European Union, thank you very much. You can sell your products elsewhere.
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Europe section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH



From DER SPIEGEL

European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Early Election

Marines Case Stokes Italy-India Tensions


Facebook
Twitter