The Right Wing and the Roma EU Presidency a Test for Tolerance in Hungary

Hungary will assume the six-month rotating presidency of the European Union in January and the government is pledging to forge a policy for addressing the Roma in all of Europe. But the country has its own troubling history with the Roma, who have been deeply impoverished and pushed to the margins of society since the fall of the Iron Curtain.

Siobhán Dowling

By Siobhán Dowling in Budapest, Hungary

Csaba Csorba is standing in scrubland beside the burned-out shell of a small house. He points to the spot amid the tall grass where he found his son Robert bleeding in the snow almost two years ago. Nearby lay the body of his four-year-old grandson Robi. The small boy had been shot through the head, his face was unrecognizable.

The murders of Feb. 23, 2009 saw the Hungarian village of Tatárszentgyörgy become synonymous with hate, hatred towards Europe's Roma people. Robert Csorba, a 27-year-old father of three, had gathered up his young son in his arms and ran out to escape the flames that engulfed his house, the last one on the edge of the village. Unknown assailants had attacked under the cover of night, throwing Molotov cocktails at the door and then opening fire when those inside tried to flee. Robert was shot in the lungs and lived for another hour, dying on the way to the hospital. His six-year-old daughter Bianka was injured but survived, while his wife Renata and younger son escaped the blaze.

There is no indication that the murderers even knew who their victims were. "The attackers didn't really care who they killed," Robert's father says today.

Csorba, a short stocky man who is missing many teeth, looks at least 10 years older than his 47 years. He believes his son might have survived if he had received proper medical attention. "The ambulance only came an hour and a half after we called, even though the hospital is five minutes away, and it didn't have oxygen," he claims. And he alleges that when the police arrived, they said the fire had been caused by electrical problems, and that the doctor claimed his son's wounds had been caused by nails from falling beams and not gunfire.

It was only after the intervention of Viktória Mohácsi, a Roma politician who at the time was a member of the European Parliament, that the investigation into the deaths became a murder enquiry. Last year, four men were arrested in connection with the crime, tracked down through mobile phone records. But the suspects have yet to face trial.

Tough Questions as Hungary Takes EU Helm

The Csorba family were the latest victims in a series of attacks on Hungary's Roma that shocked the world in early 2009. Now, two years later, Hungary is about to take the helm of the rotating European Union presidency, and leaders in Budapest say a central plank in the country's EU agenda will be addressing the issue of the Roma. But how much leadership can be expected from a country in which hatred of the Roma is part of every-day discourse and where an avowedly anti-Roma party regularly attracts the support of almost one-fifth of the electorate?

The new center-right government under Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, elected in April, has pledged to forge an EU-wide policy for addressing the Roma issue during its six months of leadership in Brussels. "By the end of the Hungarian presidency, the European Union will have a Roma policy," Orbán told state news agency MTI in late December. The Hungarian leader said a draft policy would be presented in the spring. "The European Roma strategy has to lay emphasis on education and employment," he said.

The issue took center-stage in EU politics this summer following the expulsions of around 3,000 Roma from France. The EU rapped Paris on the knuckles for its actions, saying it had contravened rules on the freedom of movement of EU citizens, though it desisted from accusing the government of French President Nicolas Sarkozy of discrimination against an ethnic group.

The events of this summer brought into sharp relief the fact that Europe's largest minority group, with a population estimated at between 10 and 12 million, is living in poverty. Yet the Roma issue, in both eastern and western Europe, often focuses just on the problems the Roma pose, for example as a security or public order issue, rather than the troubles they themselves face, from massive unemployment, poor access to education, to discrimination and in the worst cases, anti-Roma violence, including murder. And the wave of hate crimes against the Roma in Hungary in 2008 and 2009, along with the rise of the fiercely anti-Roma political party Jobbik and a general shift to the right in Hungary, raises questions about what Europe's Roma population should anticipate from the Hungarian EU presidency.

Discuss this issue with other readers!
2 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
EuroStar2011 01/03/2011
1. end the rotations
Zitat von sysopHungary will assume the six-month rotating presidency of the European Union in January and the government is pledging to forge a policy for addressing the Roma in all of Europe. But the country has its own troubling history with the Roma, who have been deeply impoverished and pushed to the margins of society since the fall of the Iron Curtain.,1518,737283,00.html
If the 50 governors of the US had to take turns to run the country nothing would ever move forward, because all they would do is talk a lot, try to align things in their favor and hand the job over to the next governor in line. The same is true for Germany, if the presidents of the "Laender" were to rotate the position of the chancellor between them everything would *rotate on the spot*. The EU would be a lot more effective and the people would be better of with a European federal government, than be stuck with this patchwork of 27 that comes and goes and never gets anyhting done.
BTraven 01/03/2011
It seems to be that under some social conditions the readiness to attack people who belong to minorities and who are very poor is increasing dramatically. Instead of expressing mercifulness to those less privileged some people resort to violence to kill them off. The poorer that people look the higher the probability that their outlook and fate create hate among a large percentage of people who have it better.
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.