Gay Comments Pope Francis Not as Liberal as He Seems

Pope Francis has sparked enthusiasm with his call for greater tolerance toward gays. But it's too soon to celebrate, says theologian David Berger. The pope's warning not to engage in gay propaganda puts him on par with homophobes like Russian President Vladimir Putin, he contends.

"According to doctrine, the homosexual act is still a sin," says theologian David Berger.

"According to doctrine, the homosexual act is still a sin," says theologian David Berger.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: On the flight from Brazil to Europe, Pope Francis was unexpectedly candid. "If someone is gay and he searches for the Lord and has good will, who am I to judge?" he said, causing many commentators to rejoice. Was this really such a big sensation?

Berger: It is incredibly naïve to liken it to a dam bursting. What are gays or lesbians to think when someone tells them: I don't want you to be discriminated against, but you are not allowed to live out your "tendency" anyway? According to doctrine, the homosexual act is still a sin. Here lies the central problem and the reason I feel further marginalized as a Catholic.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Nevertheless, Francis has explicitly opposed the exclusion of gays. Has he been urged by his advisors to do this or is a genuine concern of his?

Berger: I don't believe that it was a PR move. But he also didn't say anything revolutionary. The notion that gays shouldn't be discriminated against is already in the catechism. But when Francis says in the same breath that gays should please not advertise their sexual orientation, he puts himself in a category with Russian President Vladimir Putin, who supports laws against "homosexual propaganda."

SPIEGEL ONLINE: So this wasn't a call for greater openness of the Church?

Berger: I would like to see more openness. But there would have to be fundamental doctrinal revisions for that -- and I don't see that happening. Take Francis' categoric rejection of the ordination of women. "This door is closed," he said. This shows that when it comes to liberality, the pope is committed to the old gender roles. That's why I don't think he will be able to stop the ranks of priests from shrinking dramatically.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Is there really a so-called gay lobby in the Vatican?

Berger: There are loose networks that maintain connections in order to have sex without being discovered. But there is no organized group that advocates gay rights and wants to change the Church's doctrine. During my time in Rome, I rather experienced the opposite. Most gay priests are very pious, well-behaved people --organizing an uprising couldn't be further from their minds.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Defensive personalities who can be blackmailed because of their sexual orientation?

Berger: Sure, it's always about power. It is common knowledge in the Catholic Church that supervisors put pressure on gay priests in order to exploit them for their own interests.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Since Bergoglio became pope, Italian gay activists say their relationship with the Church has already improved.

Berger: Francis's remarks may well bring about improvement in the predominantly Catholic countries. But in Germany we are having this discussion on a different level. As a gay man in Italy, you are satisfied just to get the crumbs that fall from the table of the lord. There, gentle discrimination is already a step forward. It's completely different in Berlin or in Cologne: We have no need to eat the crumbs. Either we sit at the table or we will not take part in the dinner.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: Francis says that any form of lobbying is harmful, making reference to the Freemasons and other political forces in the Vatican. Where does the pope stand theologically?

Berger: While John Paul II and Benedict XVI could be gauged, that's not possible with Francis. His theology is rather a kind of folk Catholicism of Latin American origin. Much of what is currently fascinating believers is really the Catholic version of the rites of popular evangelical sects. For example, when he asks people at his discretion to bless him before he does it himself, he is acting out a blessing rite of the Pentecostals.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: You get the feeling that the new pope expresses himself without much precision and sometimes contradictorily, which leads to misunderstandings.

Berger: Yes, that's right. Benedict XVI spoke as he would have written. Almost everything he said was well thought out in every detail. Francis's statements often contradict each other. So he first said that atheists are devils, only to say shortly later that they are just as good as Christians. Then it was up to his spokesman to correct the statements and put them into perspective accordingly. From an intellectual perspective, the election of Francis is a fiasco for the Catholic Church. But the general public is presumably already won over by his charisma.

SPIEGEL ONLINE: What about the celibacy rules under Francis?

Berger: There is currently a lot of movement on this, which is also supported by conservative forces. But from a pedagogical standpoint, nothing will really change. The prohibition of sex remains the most important factor of the Church's power.

Interview conducted by Annette Langer


Discuss this issue with other readers!
5 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
Jim in MD 07/31/2013
1. Imprecise Theologian
If Dr. Berger really is advocating gay sex as good as heterosexual married monogamy, then he isn't much of a Catholic theologian. Centuries from now, children will wonder how some Catholics split hairs over monogamy, marriage and sexual orientation. Until a generation ago, no one had difficulty understanding the clear wording of so many theological sources throughout history. The problem that this generation has with Christianity clearly belongs to its own time and place, whether in Germany or Italy or elsewhere.
titus_norberto 08/01/2013
2. To be honest, As a Catholic myself I do not care what David Berger says....
I do not know who David Berger is and I do not care what he says.... I do not know why Der Spiegel asks David Berger about the Pope... Is David Catholic ? What is David Berger's opinion in quantum mechanics or entomology ? Please, let us be more RELEVANT. This is not an exception…. Most media grants “authority” to people who does not have it or does not deserve it. Why don’t Der Spiegel ask a RELEVANT Catholic ?
zkkhan 08/01/2013
3. New Pope!
"From an intellectual perspective, the election of Francis is a fiasco for the Catholic Church. But the general public is presumably already won over by his charisma" To win religious war one has to struggle with three groups. First and top most are intellectuals who serve like brain in body. Second are the students and thrid are the masses. How new pope is winning one can judge from this point of view.
kmshaw 08/01/2013
4. Inaccurate
Annette Langer should know by now that "homophobe" means "fear of". This is an inaccurate and derogatory label thrown at any one who disagrees with the gay agenda. Like most people, I have no fear of homosexuals and I bear them no ill will. However, like my Russian cousins, I see their constant publicity campaigns as a way to recruit adolescents who may be going thru a phase of sexual ambiguity. After all, there are young celebrities who are talking about their bi-sexual lifestyle. Talk about a confusing message to adolescents. No church or religion should be pressured to change it's original teachings just to make 3% of the population feel more normal, inclusive, warm & fuzzy or whatever word fits. Homosexuality has always existed and will always exist, but that doesn't mean it should be promoted as just another lifestyle choice. This is what 90% of Russians (not just Putin) believe and this is not homophobia.
bcprieb 08/02/2013
5. optional
It looks to me as if the Pope is reading the Bible and not just the "Catholic" teachings.
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.