Spy-Proofing: Deutsche Telekom Pushes for All-German Internet

By and

Would an all-German Internet really protect Germans from prying eyes? Zoom
DPA

Would an all-German Internet really protect Germans from prying eyes?

Recent revelations about NSA spying have given fresh impetus to the dream of a purely German Internet. Deutsche Telekom believes it could introduce a system safe from prying foreign surveillance, but some criticize the plan as pointless.

Even before it emerged that the National Security Agency had wiretapped her mobile phone, German ChancellorAngela Merkel was calling for the Internet to have something like Airbus -- a joint European initiative able to compete with the dominance of American and Chinese high-tech companies, just as Airbus does with the US aerospace giant Boeing.

Currently, the global market for software and online services is firmly in American hands. What's more, American corporations, such as Google, are subject to the Patriot Act, which requires them to allow American intelligence agencies access to their data centers.

On the other hand, the equipment that directs traffic on the Internet often comes from China -- for example, routers made by Huawei. "No one can be certain that there isn't spying technology built in there as well," warns Norbert Pohlmann, chair of the IT Security Association Germany (TeleTrust).

The new plan would foster more than just German IT start-ups. The simple message politicians and businesses are selling to the general public is that, in the best-case scenario, data shouldn't leave its home country at all, so as not to be susceptible to monitoring or interception by foreign powers.

However, at the moment, only around 40 percent of German Internet traffic is conducted between domestic computers. The infrastructure for this traffic is provided by German telecommunication companies such as 1&1 and Deutsche Telekom. But some Internet service providers also use American providers, such as Level 3 Communications, for data transfer. That means that even if the actual bits never leave Germany's borders, the NSA could still access them, although the company vehemently denies this. "Around 30 percent of domestic German Internet traffic is susceptible to surveillance," Pohlmann estimates.

Deutsche Telekom wants to change this state of affairs by building a purely German Internet, with data packets only sent via German pathways if the sender and recipient are both within the country.

Keeping Data Completely Inside Germany

The company is hard at work on technical solutions for such an "Internetz" -- a hybrid of "Internet" and the German word for "network." Managers at Deutsche Telekom say they are in talks with various network operators, looking to bring them onboard with this idea of a unified German solution and to set prices for shared use of the necessary infrastructure.

The technical investment required for the project appears to be less than initially believed, with the main task being to adapt software to the new system. Deutsche Telekom technicians now believe they may even be able to create a network for the whole of the Schengen zone, allowing the 26 countries in this area without border controls to securely exchange data among themselves. The United Kingdom, however, which works closely with the NSA, would not be part of the network.

Deutsche Telekom hopes the German government will pass the laws needed to provide a sound legal foundation for the project as well as to implement it more quickly. Without that legal framework, the company says, there is a risk that competitors or users might file lawsuits claiming discrimination or the curtailment of data traffic.

Critics, however, accuse the company of concocting nothing more than an advertising stunt. The point of a German-only Internet becomes moot, they say, the moment a customer uses services, such as Google, that transfer their data traffic using foreign infrastructure and thereby renders it subject to the laws of those countries.

Translated from the German by Ella Ornstein

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
3 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. What's the Point?
Jim in MD 11/12/2013
Of course, the power of the internet is that it really isn't nationalized. If Germany wonders about national networks, they can look at China or North Korea or Libya's old setup. The irony is that the US largely has left the internet alone, while ministers in Brussels want all sorts of "safeties" and controls. Be careful you don't kill the goose that lays the golden eggs!
2. One man's misery is another man's coins
aasalem 11/13/2013
Snooping got into many sectors then extortion became a fear to business and private individuals. Now this corporations has a new product to sale "violation free communications".
3. The NSA is ONLY ONE of MANY
fung.pee 11/14/2013
The NSA might be the target, but it should be remembered that the GCHQ is an even played in spying on Europe. Government agreements mean little. Station SOUNDER, located on a British base in Agios Nikolaos, Cyprus is where the GCHQ taps into the Middle East cables. There is an agreement between the Cypriot and UK governments restricting the spies to UK nationals. The Americans around Agios Nikolaos are actually NSA spies who are are instructed to dress 'incognito'. Their presence is contrary to the agreement signed by the British and Cypriot governments. Hey, whenever has a piece of paper ever stopped governments from screwing each other?
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Germany section
RSS

SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH



From DER SPIEGEL

Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: German-US No-Spy Pact Unlikely
Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: Spying on Merkel?


European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Garlasco Acquittals Overturned

Anti-Europe Fever


Facebook
Twitter