The Chancellor and the NSA: Merkel Has Abandoned the Germans

A Commentary By

German Chancellor Angela Merkel: Disinterested, indifferent and trivial Zoom
AP

German Chancellor Angela Merkel: Disinterested, indifferent and trivial

Incredible revelations are coming to light in the biggest spying scandal in history. And what is the German government doing? Chancellor Merkel kept silent for weeks, and then she said nothing. Her challenger in the September election, Peer Steinbrück, is correct when he says she violated her oath of office.

"I swear that I will dedicate my efforts to the well-being of the German people, promote their welfare, protect them from harm, uphold and defend the Basic Law and the laws of the Federation, perform my duties conscientiously, and do justice to all. So help me God."

The oath of office of the German president or chancellor isn't something to be taken lightly. It is anchored as Article 56 in Germany's constitution, the Basic Law. Merkel has sworn it. Over the weekend, her challenger to become the next chancellor, Peer Steinbrück of the center-left Social Democratic Party, said, "My understanding of protecting the German people from harm is a different one." He was right.

Once you get past all the rhetoric, what is the actual issue we're dealing with here? The United States has massively and systematically violated the civil rights of people who have no possbility of voting against its practices in elections. After all, the NSA and CIA and whatever the other organizations are called aren't operating under German laws when they're supposedly protecting the security of the free world.

And this about our loyalty to America. Or international terrorism. Or even the role of intelligence services. Everyone has their own opinion about that. This is about our rights being violated without us being able to resist it. We stop being citizens and turn into subjects.

It's a fundamental experience in German history that we never want to repeat. So who do we turn to now? Who is going to help us?

It appears that Germans can't rely on their own government to do the job. Chancellor Angela Merkel first remained silent for weeks about the biggest espionage scandal in history. When she finally did speak out, she said very little.

In the interview she gave the weekly Die Zeit last week, it was clear what she thought of the matter -- she was uninterested, indifferent. It was almost surreal. Edward Snowden had revealed to the public that our "allies" tap some 500 million data connections in Germany each month and, in doing so, violate a host of German laws -- not to mention trust among political friends -- and all the chancellor can do is offer a few stanzas that clearly betray her boredom with the issue, acting as if this all has nothing to do with her.

A Disproportionate Violation

"A balance must always be maintained when it comes to freedom and security," Merkel says. "That is why everything has to be done according to the principle of proportionality." Yes, the reader wants to shout, that's totally right, but the disproportionate violation of this principle is precisely the problem here! Yet the chancellor remains mum.

In the current issue of SPIEGEL, deputy editor-in-chief Klaus Brinkbäumer describes the United States as a country that is sick, wounded and unsettled. "Since 2005, an average of 23 Americans per year have been killed through terrorism, mostly outside of the US." "More Americans die of falling televisions and other appliances than from terrorism," Nicholas Kristof recently wrote in the New York Times, and "15 times as many die by falling off ladders." Those figures haven't stopped the US military from spending $8 trillion on the military and homeland security since 2001.

It is kind of Brinkbäumer to diagnose the American data totalitarianism as a symptom of paranoid delusions. Hunger for power would be another explanation. In any event, it is the duty of the chancellor and her ministers to protect Germans from the consequences. But they have failed to live up to this responsibility. Not the chancellor, who instead prefers to point out the services the US did for Germany during the reunification process. Nor her interior minister, who allowed himself to be treated like some kind of obedient schoolboy during his visit to Washington late last week. He said he would have "clear words" with the Americans. But before Hans-Peter Friedrich even boarded his plane, his staff were already conveying to him that he couldn't count on getting details about the NSA surveillance programs when he got to Washington. It was all classified as "top secret" and "NOFORN" ("no foreign nationals").

Merkel Isn't Powerless, She Just Doesn't Care

It was the kind of uncomfortable feeling of powerlessness one knows from surreal dreams. The German interior minister travels to Washington to complain about spying by US agencies against Germans and he is then told that the activities of US intelligence services cannot be discussed because they are classified.

But Hans Peter Friedrich didn't feel humiliated in Washington. He was pleased to have been received at all. He also had a few statistics that he could take back home with him. Back in Germany, Friedrich announced that 45 terrorist attacks had been prevented around the world thanks to information supplied by US intelligence services. Some 25 were in Europe, including five in Germany.

But there was one question that remained unanswered. What was the bigger insult to the German people -- that the Americans didn't even think it was necessary to justify their spying to the Germans? Or the Mickey Mouse numbers they gave our interior minister for which there is no proof and which may or may not be true?

Why is Merkel doing this? Europe and Germany aren't powerless against American encroachments. The European Union's data protection directive includes provisions to force US firms to ahere to our rules. And the US has just as much interest in a free trade agreement as the Europeans. Merkel is not powerless, she just doesn't care. She has always operated without any appreciable convictions. And where there are no convictions, there can be no outrage either.

In Grosseto, Italy, a trial against Francesco Schettino is currently underway. As captain, he drove the Costa Concordia aground off the island of Giglio. The charges against him claim that he deserted both the ship and his passengers. In the spying scandal, Angela Merkel is our Captain Schettino. She has left the Germans in the lurch.

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
9 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. optional
peskyvera 07/16/2013
Paying a high price, but perhaps now Germany and so many Germans will realize that the Yanks are NOT best friends - they only look after themselves. Stop sucking up to them. 'Amerika' doesn't come by friends naturally...
2. French spying
sharon_st100 07/16/2013
Very telling there is no mention of France's own prism spy program which Le Monde exposed. France also spies on Germany but this would spoil the narrative of Europe/good and America/bad that the EU and its cohorts in the European media need . France spying on the Germany is more explosive because it is France which is supposed to have special relationship with Germany of the famous Franco-German partnership which is building "EUROPE". The USA has never pretended who its special relationship is with the British.
3. French spying
richardborley 07/16/2013
How right Sharon is. Sadly Spiegel seems to have too many correspondents who are extremely naive and curiously liberal in their views. Get real and join the real world.
4. optional
reindm 07/16/2013
First thing I learned when I got interested in politics: Don't ever trust the Americans. Therefore never trust Frau Merkel, she is power hungry -- a bad desease.
5. Thoughts from an American
bucky19701951x 07/16/2013
First, everyone is spying on each other. Next, please do not refer the American people when really you are angry (as we are) with our current government administration. But it is so strange that your government would challenge Obama's administration with the US Dollars you get for free. Those dollars being sent to Germany are to buy your government's support. As much as you dislike this; we Americans aren't happy either. Shame governments aren't supporting the people they represent. But you are right, my government needs to get out of everyone's business!
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Germany section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH




About Jakob Augstein
Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: Timeline of the NSA Spying Scandal


European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Renzi Ups the Pace

50 Italians Fighting with ISIS


Facebook
Twitter