Altruistic Society or Sect? The Shadowy World of the Islamic Gülen Movement

By Maximilian Popp

Part 2: 'You Must Move in the Arteries of the System'

Photo Gallery: The Mysterious Gülen Movement Photos
AP

The Gülen movement has two sides: One that faces the world and another that hides from it. Its finances are particularly murky. Rich businessmen donate millions, but civil servants and skilled manual workers also contribute to the financing of Gülen projects. Fethullahcis donate an average of 10 percent of their income to the community, with some giving up to 70 percent.

Gülen likes to portray himself as a modest preacher akin to a Muslim Gandhi. One of his mantras is: "Build schools instead of mosques."

But before he moved to the United States, Gülen treated the West as the enemy. "Until the day of judgment," he wrote in his book "Cag ve Nesil" (This Era and the Young Generation), "Westerners will exhibit no human behavior." Gülen condemned Turks who embraced Europe as "freeloaders," "parasites" and "leukemia." In a November 2011 video message, he called upon the Turkish military to attack Kurdish separatists: "Locate them, surround them, break up their units, let fire rain down upon their houses, drown out their lamentations with even more wails, cut off their roots and put an end to their cause."

Gülen also disputes the theory of evolution, calling it "unscientific" and an "illusion." He believes that scientific facts are only true if they agree with the Koran.

Calls for a New Muslim Age

Gülen grew up as the son of a village imam in Anatolia. He studied at a mosque in Erzurum, a city in eastern Turkey, together with Cemaleddin Kaplan, who would later move to Germany where he was known as the "Caliph of Cologne" because of his radical preaching. At the same time, Gülen encountered the teachings of Said Nursi, a Kurdish Sufi preacher, and joined his community.

When Ankara, in its fight against communism in the 1980s, invoked the ideology of the "Turkish-Islamic synthesis," Gülen seized the opportunity. He founded schools in Turkey and abroad, and he became an adviser to the strictly secular prime minister, Tansu Ciller.

In one of his sermons, he called upon his students to establish a new Muslim age. He advised his supporters to undermine the Turkish state and act conspiratorially until the time was ripe to assume power. "You must move in the arteries of the system without anyone noticing your existence until you reach all the power centers … until the conditions are ripe, they (the followers) must continue like this. If they do something prematurely, the world will crush our heads, and Muslims will suffer everywhere. (…) You must wait until such time as you have gotten all the state power (…) Until that time, any step taken would be too early -- like breaking an egg without waiting the full 40 days for it to hatch. It would be like killing the chick inside."

When a recording of this speech was leaked to the public in 1999, Gülen had to flee from Turkey. He claims that his words were manipulated. He has been living in exile in the United States ever since.

No Address and No Bank Account

His movement has no address, no mailbox, no registration and no central bank account. Gülen supporters don't demonstrate for sharia and jihad, and the cemaat operates in secret. Gülen, the godfather, determines the movement's direction. Some members within the inner circle of power have been serving Gülen for decades. They control the most important organizations within the movement, the publishing houses and foundations. Within the cemaat, individual world regions, like Central Asia and Europe, are managed by a "brother." The hierarchy extends all the way down to national and local "brothers" in city neighborhoods.

Gülen's influence in Turkey was enhanced when Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's conservative Islamic party, the AKP, won the Turkish parliamentary election in 2002. Observers believe that the two camps entered into a strategic partnership at first, with Gülen providing the AKP with votes while Erdogan protected the cemaat. According to information obtained by US diplomats, almost a fifth of the AKP's members of parliament were members of the Gülen movement in 2004, including the justice and culture ministers.

Many civil servants act at the behest of the "Gülen brothers," says a former senior member. "They were our students. We trained and supported them. When these grateful children assume office, they continue to serve Gülen." In 2006, former police chief Adil Serdar Sacan estimated that the Fethullahcis held more than 80 percent of senior positions in the Turkish police force. "The assertion that the TNP (Turkish National Police) is controlled by Gulenists is impossible to confirm but we have found no one who disputes it," wrote James Jeffrey, the then US ambassador in Ankara, in a 2009 cable.

Good Muslims

Ercan Karakoyun is the face of the Gülen community in Germany. The 31-year-old runs the Forum for Intercultural Dialogue (FID) in Berlin, which has Gülen as its honorary chairman. Karakoyun, the son of Turkish immigrants, meets with visitors in an office at the city's prestigious Potsdamer Platz which has light-blue carpeting and plain, functional furniture. The bookshelf contains works by Gülen, "The Diary of Anne Frank," "The Bible in Fair Language" (a new German translation of the Bible which aims to be free of gender bias and anti-Semitism) and a book by the late German Protestant theologian Heinz Zahrnt. The book selection seems balanced and judicious, with a little of everything and nothing too controversial. It seems intended to convey the following message to visitors: Look, we're good Muslims. We mourn the dead of the Holocaust, we are interested in theological discussions of Christianity and we are democrats.

Karakoyun found his way to the movement through a "brother" who addressed him in front of a mosque in the western state of North Rhine-Westphalia when he was a teenager. He began reading Gülen's books. He accompanied the "brother" to Turkey and became involved in the cemaat, recruiting new members at the university and in high schools. He rose up through the hierarchy until he became a "brother" himself.

Speaking in eloquent German, Karakoyun says that whenever he and his Gülen community organize events, they receive letters, emails and calls from what he terms "the usual suspects" -- people who want to harm the movement and see it as a dangerous sect. He characterizes all of this as "conspiracy theories.'

Karakoyun divides the world into two groups: "critics" and "sympathizers." As examples of critics, he cites Western Islamophobes, Turkish ultranationalists and the terrorists of the Kurdish PKK. Sympathizers, he says, are all people who are interested in "dialogue, tolerance and peaceful coexistence for the benefit of all."

'Anyone who Messes with Gülen Is Destroyed'

All of this sounds harmless, tolerant and peaceful. But Ilhan Cihaner experienced in Turkey what can happen to critics. "Anyone who messes with Gülen is destroyed," says the former chief prosecutor. He has been a hero among secular Turks since he investigated the Gülen community in 2007. Cihaner says that he had received information about illegal financial transactions within the cemaat. But then, in response to pressure from the government, he was taken off the case. He was arrested in 2010.

Cihaner was accused of being a member of the ultranationalist Ergenekon organization, a group of conspirators who had allegedly planned to overthrow the government. Even Cihaner's political rivals believe that the charges against him were absurd. The former prosecutor had acquired a reputation for his staunch campaigns against mafia-like networks. And now he was being accused of working with Ergenekon and planning to plant weapons in dormitories where Gülen supporters lived so as to discredit the movement. The prosecution based its case on statements by anonymous witnesses. Cihaner was eventually released because of insufficient evidence against him. He is now a member of the opposition in the Turkish parliament.

Istanbul-based journalist Ahmet Sik suffered a similar fate. He was arrested in March 2011, shortly before his book about the Gülen movement, "Imamin Ordusu," ("The Imam's Army"), was to be published. Security forces searched the offices of his publishing house, and the manuscript, in which Sik describes how the Gülen movement has allegedly infiltrated the police and the judiciary in Turkey, was confiscated. The investigative reporter was charged with being a member of Ergenekon. Ironically, it was Sik who, together with a colleague, had exposed the secret coup plans of an Ergenekon admiral in the weekly magazine Nokta in 2007 and who had repeatedly targeted the Ergenekon network. Sik was released a few months ago, following international protests.

In September 2010, Hanefi Avci, a former Turkish police chief and former Gülen sympathizer, was arrested and accused of having participated in the Ergenekon conspiracy. He had just published a book in which he accused Gülen members in the police of illegally wiretapping their enemies' telephone conversations and manipulating trials.

Lies and Manipulation

There is no evidence that Gülen was behind the arrests. He lives a reclusive life in the Pennsylvania mountains and behaves as if the accusations have nothing to do with him. He declined a request to be interviewed by SPIEGEL.

Others speak on his behalf, like Mahmut Cebi, the former editor-in-chief of the pro-Gülen newspaper Zaman, whose office is in the World Media Group building in Offenbach near Frankfurt. Cebi built up the European edition of Zaman and has worked as an writer for the publishing company since April. The European edition has about 30,000 subscribers in Germany alone.

Cebi and Zaman explain to readers what the world looks like from the perspective of the cemaat. The newspaper prints the writings of Gülen and excerpts from his sermons and poems. Critics accuse Zaman of deliberately spreading false reports to harm Gülen's opponents.

When politicians in Germany's far-left Left Party criticized Gülen's remarks on the Kurds a few weeks ago, Zaman claimed that the Left Party supports the banned Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK).

"The movement is up to its neck in dirty tricks," Dani Rodrik, a professor of international political economy at Harvard University, said in a recent interview. Zaman, he added, supports this "mafia" with "false and misleading accounts" and "manipulations." "There is no disinformation they will not peddle to further the causes they support," said Rodrik.

Cebi denies all accusations. His newspaper is guided by Gülen's ideals, he says, but it doesn't take orders from him. Gülen is not a sect leader, says Çebi. Instead, he compares him to one of Germany's leading public intellectuals: "He's a philosopher like Habermas."

Translated from the German by Christopher Sultan

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
7 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. It is not shadowy, it is crystal clear
sahinyavuzturk@gmail.com 08/10/2012
The Gulen movement is not shadowy, it is open to anyone and crystal clear. You can get more information about Gulen Movement and its pillars from official pages: http://www.GulenMovement.ca & http://en.fgulen.com/
2. Typical
europeforever 08/14/2012
Hello, this article sounds like a typical "turkish" article and not like a neutral SPIEGEL-article. It`s normal that some people want to disturb the good atmosphere during the holy month ramadan by writing bad things about people like Mr Gülen, who spent their whole lives for peace an dialogue.
3. fethullah gulen and infiltration
owa72 08/14/2012
china and russland banned this sects activity a while ago... they seem to be aware where this movement comes from and who is building and backing up this sect. african countries seem to be to helpless to realize what this movement under the umbrella of charity is really carrying in to their countries. for a very long time the german intelligence service did not have any published reports about this sect. they let them willingly operate and grow everywhere in german cities, suburbs and rural areas. starting with activly spotting and inviting important personals in neighbourhoods to their circles of religious conversations, surrounding them and finally it become a social pressure to join their meetings. within this circles the next level is recruited as decribed in the article. and it goes on and on with this recruitments. in the meantime they have build up a financial networks, educational instituions for tutoring and for achieving degrees which are difficult to get for immigrant children, and providing "safe" marriage opportunites for urban muslim women who by divorce for example got socially lost more or less... anytime the gulen movement can import any important person for their sect-system by marriage to any place in the world. I could observe the establishing process of several schools in germany and I was more than astonished by the naivete of town councils who were invited to trips to turkey to see gülen educational work in turkey and enjoy extra holiday in turkey. the trips were all paid by this sect. but they are not free of cost for any society. and the cost for germany is getting infiltrated by this sect which is obviously following takkiya... and even for hardcore fundamentalists, its not so sure for whom they are doing this "takkiya"-strategy. at the moment fethullah gülen followers are already in important instituions in germany. they sit in the secret service, they are in education, they are even active in the christian democrat party, not to mention all the others... in turkey, where they are already wiretapping and videotaping and blackmailing all kinds of people of public interest, they are since many years already in control. There are just few people who dont bow to their authority. İt makes me wonder why nothing really relevant about fethullah gulen and his followers is published in english, especially in usa where they are so active. But on the other hand, what recep tayyip erdogan pretends to be on the political level in middle east, fethullah gülen is forseen to become on the religious level. and besides preaching religious tolarance... turkey never had so bad relationships with israel like right now, the religious minorities in turkey have never being so much under pressure and it makes me wonder why some christian orthodox in istanbul still claim, its better than never before... I can just assume, that they dont want themself to become spotted targets for society. big ups, and big thanks for having the courage to report about fethullah gulen and his deceptive practices.
4.
vodemi 08/16/2012
I think this article is not based on real facts but on strange accusions and prejudice. There is no evidence for the statements and there are only speculations. Actually I first read this article in German last week, and the movementis described as sect/mafia/turkish ghandi/opus dei.. all in one. This article is not professional and it doesn't consider recent researches from scientist about the movement. I think this article from Popp is kind of shame for Der Spiegel that usually offers more quality articles. I would advise them to excuse for this crap but I know they won't. I think the movement is very clear, most people in the movement are religious, conservative and modern, honest and open-minded for every human. They have no criminal aims or plans. This article is too low for Spiegel-Magazine. Regards, student from Germany.
5. optional
bonobo2000 12/28/2013
this article contains all the typical biases of European views on Islam and Turks. therefore it relies more on prejudices rather than facts. i have nothing to do with guelen movement, but I am aware that there are only a few scholar works that deals with the topic and one of them published in Springer (!) available online.
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Germany section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2012
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH



From DER SPIEGEL
Graphic: The Gülen empire Zoom
DER SPIEGEL

Graphic: The Gülen empire



European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Centre-left Takes Emilia and Calabria

Rome Metro Shambles


Facebook
Twitter