Boy, Girl, Other: Intersex Advocates Call for Surgery Ban

By Irene Habich

Surgically assigning gender to an intersex child at birth violates the right to bodily integrity, activists say. Zoom
Corbis

Surgically assigning gender to an intersex child at birth violates the right to bodily integrity, activists say.

A new law in Germany allows parents to leave their child's gender blank on birth certificates. Intersex activists are pleased, but want to go further. Often themselves scarred by invasive operations performed at birth, some want to prohibit sex reassignment surgeries on children.

Expectant parents look forward to that moment when they sit in the doctor's office and look at the ultrasound picture. Will it be a boy or a girl? And yet sometimes the answer is not immediately clear, even after the child is born.

Approximately one out of every 4,500 babies is born intersex, with genital anomalies. The external sex organs may not correspond with the internal sex organs, or with the child's chromosomal sex. A baby with the male Y chromosome may appear as a girl, or a baby with two X chromosomes may appear as a boy. Combinations of testicles and ovaries, or a clitoris and penis are possible.

On Nov. 1, Germany began offering parents the option of declining to choose a gender for their child on birth certificates, allowing intersex babies to grow up and decide for themselves what their gender is.

Lucie Veith, chair of the German Association of Intersex People, calls the change "a step in the right direction." She says she fears the law may have downsides, like if children are "forced out of the closet" in schools and left vulnerable to discrimination. Her organization is also calling for the German government to take the reform even further. They want to ban doctors and parents from surgically assigning children their sex at birth. Veith says such operations are mostly medically unnecessary.

"The right to bodily integrity is violated," she says, referring to one of the fundamental human rights listed in the Basic Law, Germany's constitution. The activist organization Zwischengeschlecht.org says these sex assignment surgeries amount to "mutilating cosmetic operations on the genitals of children" that have to be put to a stop.

'Routine Sexual Invasion'

Many intersex adults experienced painful and traumatic treatments in their childhood, and controversial medical interventions are still common. After a vaginoplasty, or the surgical construction of a vagina, for example, dilators have to be inserted on a regular basis for the rest of the person's life to prevent the vaginal walls from collapsing. "I've heard from many who experienced that as a kind of routine sexual invasion," Veith says.

The decision to live as a man or woman, or to live outside the gender binary, should rest with the individual, Veith says, once they've reached sexual maturity. Her organization calls for a legal ban on any medically unnecessary interventions before the child's 16th birthday.

"Efforts to produce an unambiguous body impose circumstances upon the child that it may not want," says sexual scientist Hertha Richter-Appelt of the University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf. Nevertheless, not all people who received sex assignment surgery as children are unhappy later in life, she adds -- intersex children may later resent their parents' decision, regardless of whether or not they received the operation.

"When the issue is definitively deciding what is truly better for the children, we have to be honest and say that we often don't know," Richter-Appelt says. She recommends holding off on treatments to assign gender until the child hits puberty.

When -- Or If -- To Operate

Susanne Krege is a surgeon at the Maria-Hilf Hospital in the western German city of Krefeld who specializes in intersex children, most often children who are genetically female with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH). This class of genetic conditions causes irregular hormone production that begins in utero. Girls with CAH often produce too much male hormones, meaning they can be born with an abnormally large clitoris that may look like a small penis. A common treatment is the surgical reduction of the clitoris, which can reduce sexual sensitivity later in life.

That, however, is uncommon with the most current surgical methods, Krege says. She performs the operation on babies only when the parents strongly insist on it, she says, and usually recommends waiting until the child develops. She offers vaginoplasty when the child is mature enough to perform the dilation herself. And in cases of children with undescended testicles, she also recommends waiting before surgically intervening. Removal of the testicles requires lifelong hormone replacement therapy, which can greatly increase the risk for cancer.

Intersex advocacy groups say operations are still performed much too early. Krege, however, says that "doctors who deal with the issue more intensively don't do that anymore." She recommends coming up with new guidelines.

Lucie Veith says she's not just concerned with when to perform surgery, but also whether it is necessary at all: "You can be happy as an intersex person too," she says.

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
3 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. ....
harry.haddad 11/01/2013
Who are we to decide whether there should only be a male or a female? Why can't there be anything in between, and why cannot we treat a baby as such as a unique entity?
2.
mision2mars 11/02/2013
I would like to congratulate Germany on this most recent progress on civil rights and equality. I grew up in a country where not only gender is assigned to babies and sexual orientation is assumed to be always straight, but also religion is registered at birth. I had been given an identity that was never me, never described or defined me. Not forcefully defining babies into categories is critical in allowing them freedom in their later life. On the surgical intervention front, many post-natal gender assignment surgeries lead to loss of fertility robbing the individual of their very basic right to reproduction. This is utterly unacceptable. Similarly, loss of tissue in gender assignment surgeries may lead to loss of or reduction in sexual function or pleasure later in life. Babies should not be surgically altered merely for the purpose of fitting them into traditional or religious norms of gender. Any unnecessary surgery on non-consenting babies or children, especially those with loss of tissue, including circumcision, mount to mutilation.
3. German naming laws
leslilanning 11/03/2013
I have heard that due to German naming laws, you must be able to tell the gender of the child by the first name. I've always found this unbelievable since gender ambiguous names are so common in many countries and also because there is clearly no allowance for people who are somewhere in the middle - either physically or socially. I wonder how this will work now that parents no longer need to identify the sex and gender of the child at birth.
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Germany section
RSS

SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH





European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Garlasco Acquittals Overturned

Anti-Europe Fever


Facebook
Twitter