No Justice for El-Masri Germany Drops Pursuit of CIA Kidnappers
The German government has said it will not pursue extradition requests for 13 CIA agents charged with kidnapping a German citizen and taking him to Afghanistan for interrogation and abuse. Relations with the US government, Berlin says, are more important.
Khaled el-Masri was kidnapped and held for five months by US CIA agents.
Now, though, in the face of US intransigence, Germany has backed down. SPIEGEL has discovered that, in order to avoid a conflict with Washington, Berlin has decided to forgo forwarding a formal request that the agents be arrested. Germany's Justice Ministry sent out a feeler in late August to determine how Washington might react to such a request. The answer was clear: Washington is fundamentally unprepared to move against the agents.
Justice Minister Brigitte Zypries' decision to jettison the case doesn't just sidestep a potential trans-Atlantic spat, it also avoids a further deepening of existing tensions within Germany's governing coalition. Interior Minister Wolfgang Schäuble, a member of Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats, had promised to veto an official request if Zypries, a member of the Social Democrats, elected to pursue the case.
Khaled el-Masri, a German citizen of Lebanese descent, was abducted in December 2003 in Macedonia and taken to a prison in Kabul where he was abused. El-Masri has said he was beaten and sodomized by his captors. He was released five months later and claims his captors admitted it was a case of mistaken identity. The US has never owned up to the error, but Merkel has said that US officials acknowledged to her that they had taken el-Masri by mistake.
Human rights groups have focused on the el-Masri case in pointing out the fundamental injustices inherent in the US "extraordinary renditions" program, which sees terror suspects arrested by US agents and flown to third countries for interrogation and, it has been alleged, torture.
El-Masri, though, may have nowhere left to turn in search of justice in his case. He is pursuing civil damages in US courts, but the government in Washington is claiming state secrecy concerns and has refused to cooperate -- leaving the courts with no choice but to bar the case.
The 43-year-old el-Masri has suffered from psychological instability since his return to Germany in 2004; his lawyer Manfred Gnjidic described him as a "psychological wreck" earlier this year. In May, el-Masri was arrested for attempting to set a supermarket on fire following an argument over a defective MP3 player el-Masri had purchased at the store.
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2007
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH