'The Americans Lied' Trans-Atlantic 'No-Spy' Deal on the Rocks

Last summer, German Chancellor Angela Merkel promised her citizens a pact which would prohibit US spying on German citizens. But since then, Washington has shown little interest in pursuing such a treaty. Now, officials in Germany fear the deal is dead.

By and

Berlin wants a deal with the US that prohibits trans-Atlantic spying, but Washington seems uninterested.

Berlin wants a deal with the US that prohibits trans-Atlantic spying, but Washington seems uninterested.

Failed talks? Hardly. The negotiations "are continuing," says Germany's foreign intelligence service, the Bundesnachrichtendienst (BND). "We are still talking," says the German government. In other words, nothing has yet been decided. The No-Spy deal is still alive.

But the statements coming out of Berlin and Pullach, where the BND is headquartered, reek of forced optimism. Nobody wants it to look as though efforts have been abandoned toward a deal which would see the US agree to swear off spying operations in Germany. Yet despite the assertions, most of those involved are slowly coming to the realization that a surveillance deal between Washington and Berlin isn't likely to become reality. The US government is still digging in its heels.

On Tuesday, the German daily Süddeutsche Zeitung quoted one source who is familiar with the talks as saying "we won't get anything." The paper also reported that the US is refusing to promise that it won't monitor members of the German government and other politicians in the future.

The current gloominess is a stark shift from the confidence on display in the middle of last year. To be sure, Germany was in the middle of a general election campaign. But in the summer of 2013, National Security Agency head Keith Alexander had told his German counterpart, BND chief Gerhard Schindler, that a far-reaching deal was possible, though he also acknowledged that it was ultimately up to the White House to give the green light. German officials began speaking of the treaty as though it were a done deal.

Legal Action?

Since then, however, news broke that the US had monitored Chancellor Angela Merkel's mobile phone and that the US undertakes far-reaching surveillance activities from the roof of its embassy in Berlin. Washington has thus far refused to tell Berlin exactly when it tapped into Merkel's phone and has denied German experts access to its roof-top spying operation. The German government has informed Washington that it considers the surveillance post to be a violation of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations and it is considering taking legal action.

The mood, in short, has dramatically worsened, and US stonewalling on a No-Spy deal isn't helping. "The Americans lied to us," one high-ranking official told the Süddeutsche in reference to the treaty.

It is an extremely uncomfortable situation for German Chancellor Angela Merkel. For months, her staff, together with high-ranking officers within German security agencies, have sought to move the project forward. Sources in the government now believe that a thin declaration of intent, in which both countries pledge to obey the laws of the other, is the most that can be hoped for.

Merkel will have to take charge of the issue if she wants to achieve anything at all. She will have the opportunity to speak personally with US President Barack Obama in Washington next week. It seems likely that the chancellor will do all she can to return with something concrete. Should the two NATO allies not be able to reach agreement on a treaty preventing them from spying on one another, it would be the clearest indication yet that trans-Atlantic relations are in trouble. And it would be embarrassing for her domestically.

After all, her pledge to work towards a No-Spy deal was key to ensuring that the swelling debate over the American National Security Agency's mass surveillance practices didn't derail her re-election campaign last year. It was a message to voters that she and her conservatives were doing all they could to protect the data of German citizens. Both her then-chief of staff, Ronald Pofalla, and then-Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich used every chance they got to promise as much.

Should she fail, it will be a black mark on her credibility and make clear just how little influence Merkel has in Washington.

Overstepping Its Bounds

The revelations of widespread NSA surveillance in Europe and Germany have already hurt Merkel. Since the affair began last June, the Chancellery has been in the awkward position of not really knowing what is coming next and has seemed helpless. Interior Minister Friedrich, for his part, complained of "anti-Americanism" spoke of a "super basic right of security," and, in an interview with SPIEGEL, seemed extremely eager to counter concerns that the US was overstepping its bounds.

German government representatives seeking answers returned home from Washington empty handed and questions sent to Washington have been ignored or returned with unsatisfying responses.

Domestically this week, the issue has returned. The opposition has placed NSA surveillance and the No Spy treaty on the parliamentary agenda for Wednesday and difficult questions are sure to be asked. Members of the governing coalition, which pairs Merkel's Christian Democrats with the center-left Social Democrats, are becoming concerned as well. Stephan Meyer, domestic affairs expert for Merkel's conservatives in parliament, has even suggested that economic sanctions should be considered. "It is time," he said. "The US has to be candid."

Thomas Oppermann, floor leader for the SPD, also said that "a failure of the treaty would be unacceptable." Still, he insists that he remains optimistic. "I am hopeful that the chancellor's visit to the US will help us achieve a deal in the end."

His meaning, though, is clear. Merkel must deliver.

Discuss this issue with other readers!
18 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
marksban 01/15/2014
1. optional
So, the American government lied to the German government. Why should you be different? They've been lying to me and other U.S. citizens for years.
spon-facebook-1371746785 01/15/2014
2. optional
Let us be honest and admit, that there has not been a free, independent, European state for many years; all European states are vassals of the USA and like it like that, while posturing as powerful leaders at home or amongst each other.
muley63 01/15/2014
3. Americans Did Not Lie
Americans only said they were not recording Merkel message RIGHT now. They never made any promises about the future. Who knows what kind of stupid leaders the Germans might elect. Don't want to bring up the obvious, but you guys know who I am talking about. If Germans wanted a treaty, their own security forces have to share information. That's what the 5 Eyes have and that is to be expected from Germany. Germans need to grow up.
williger30 01/15/2014
4. Lies upon Lies
USA, has been lying,spying on the friend and allies since WW II, if our leaders are weak and stupid to take this treatment, then time to get strong minded people to tell the Yanks Go Home, and stay there, They need us more than we need them. Start with NATO, and those connected with the Bilderburg crowd. Just Remember all the wars since WW II, and see who is behind it all.
jeffwynn 01/15/2014
5. You Germans do it better...
You Germans (my Grandmother was born in Bavaria, so I guess this means 25% of me, too) do things so much better than we Americans do - so we want to peek in on you. All the time. In every way. We do a few things better here in America than you: we can kill ourselves much more efficiently with our 350,000,000 handguns, and we can spy on you better because we can apparently throw unlimited amounts of US dollars into the effort. But spying on you is a form of admiration! In the meantime, be glad you are safe in Germany. ~~~~~
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.