Interview with Asia Security Expert on North Korea: "Americans Committed a Grave Mistake"

North Korea's apparent test of a nuclear weapon has changed the security situation in Asia. SPIEGEL spoke with Yan Xuetong, Professor for International Studies at Peking's Qinghua University, about what went wrong.

The Friendship Bridge linking North Korea with China. The relationship may now have soured.

The Friendship Bridge linking North Korea with China. The relationship may now have soured.

SPIEGEL: Officially relations between China and North Korea are described as ďas close as lips and teeth.Ē Has the nuclear weapons test put an end to that?

Yan: China and North Korea are no longer close allies.

SPIEGEL: How is the relationship now?

Yan: Not normal. Chinaís relationship to North Korea is even worse than its relationship with Kenya or other African states.

SPIEGEL: Chinaís attempts to prevent Kim Jong Il from building the bomb have been in vain. What went wrong?

Yan: The Americans committed a grave mistake when they levied sanctions against North Korea and when they excluded the country from the international banking system. They also refused to rule out an attack on North Korea and did not grant Pyongyang a security guarantee. China also failed to provide North Korea with any guarantee that in the case of an attack it would be protected by Chinese atomic weapons. Which is why Kim Jong Il tested the bomb.

SPIEGEL: Did Beijing fail to exert enough pressure to dissuade him from going ahead with the test?

Yan: China pursued the correct policy by taking part in the six-party talks dealing with the North Korean atomic program, along with North Korea, South Korea, Japan, the US and Russia. Unfortunately though, Beijing didnít make enough of an effort to keep the talks going; they have been suspended for a year now. If the six-party talks had continued, maybe twice a year for example, North Korea wouldnít have gone ahead with the test.

SPIEGEL: What will be the consequences for Asia of a nuclear-armed North Korea?

Yan: To avoid a nuclear domino effect in northeastern Asia, it is crucial that China and the US work together intensively on this issue. It is even more important right now to prevent North Korea from testing a second bomb. As we heard, the first test wasnít so successful. So right now we must give the North Koreans the message: ďDonít run another test.Ē

SPIEGEL: What can Beijing or Washington offer as an incentive?

Yan: If the US lifted sanctions or declared itself ready to engage in bilateral dialogue, then that would prevent North Korea from conducting another test. At the moment though the Americans will not yield. They want to save face and donít want to bow under pressure.

SPIEGEL: Could Kimís regime collapse under the pressure of international sanctions?

Yan: No. I donít think so. People have been talking about a collapse for over 15 years. There is no sign of a quick breakup.

Interview conducted by Andreas Lorenz


All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH

International Newsletter
Sign up for our newsletter -- and get the very best of SPIEGEL in English sent to your email inbox twice weekly.