Black Helicopters: Britain's Blind Faith in Intelligence Agencies

A Commentary by Christoph Scheuermann

Photo Gallery: Harassing the Messenger Photos
AFP

Most in Britain seem unconcerned about the mass surveillance carried out by its intelligence agency GCHQ. Even the intimidation tactics being used on the Guardian this week have caused little soul-searching. The reason is simple: Britons blindly and uncritically trust their secret service.

The Snowden affair was actually going pretty well for British Prime Minister David Cameron. After the initial uproar, many of his fellow citizens quickly lost interest in the surveillance scandal and in the fact that the British intelligence agency Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) had launched what was presumably the most ambitious project ever to monitor global data communications. The opposition helped out by making itself largely invisible. And the Liberal Democrats, in a coalition government with the Conservatives, likewise did nothing despite the party's tradition of being champions of privacy protections.

The United Kingdom is not an authoritarian surveillance state like China. But it is a country in which surveillance has become part of everyday life. The cold eyes of the security apparatus keep watch over everything that moves -- in underground stations and hospitals, at intersections and on buses. The British Security Industry Authority (BSIA) recently estimated that there could be up to 5.9 million surveillance cameras in the country -- or one camera for every 11 Britons. Most were not installed by the government, but by companies and private citizens. One wonders who even has the time to look at these images.

While there is the occasional burst of resistance on the island, most just accept surveillance as the price of freedom. And, in contrast to Germany, many journalists are wont to defend their government, particularly when it comes to the global interest of the United Kingdom and its supposed national security. Dan Hodges, a blogger with ties to the Labour Party, echoed the sentiments of many in the Westminster political world following the detention of David Miranda, the partner of Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald, who has been instrumental in exposing the breadth of GCHQ and NSA surveillance activities. Hodges wrote: "What do we honestly expect the UK authorities to do? Give him a sly wink and say 'Off you go son, you have a nice trip'?"

Journalists Deferring to National Interests

It's astonishing to see how many Britons blindly and uncritically trust the work of their intelligence service. Some still see the GCHQ as a club of amiable gentlemen in shabby tweed jackets who cracked the Nazis' Enigma coding machine in World War II. The majority of people instinctively rally round their government on key issues of defense policy, sovereignty and home rule -- even though the threat to the "national security" of the UK emanating from Edward Snowden is nothing more than an allegation at the moment. Those in power in Westminster have become used to journalists deferring to national interests when it comes to intelligence issues.

The spies expect pre-emptive subservience and discretion from the country's press, and they often get what they want. There is no other explanation for the matter-of-factness with which government officials and GCHQ employees contacted Guardian editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger to demand the surrender or destruction of hard drives. What is surprising is the self-assurance that led the powerful to believe that none of this would ever come to light. According to the newspaper, after the hard drives had been destroyed in the Guardian's basement, an intelligence agent joked: "We can call off the black helicopters."

Those words reflect the government's need for chummy proximity. Journalists must avoid such attempts at ingratiation from the powerful, even if it means that they are occasionally denied information and exclusive stories from intelligence sources. The hours Miranda spent being interrogated at Heathrow Airport and the destruction of the hard drives in the Guardian basement show that the British security authorities are serious about the information war that has just begun.

Cozy Relationship

It is a war that also revolves around deterrence and intimidation. The agent's comment about the black helicopters may have been meant as a joke, but it doesn't seem all that unrealistic in the country. Why else would the government, as Rusbridger describes in detail, exert pressure on the paper long after the Snowden leaks became public?

And why else would it destroy hard drives, even though it stands to reason that the data on the drives had already been copied to other storage devices? The incident, at any rate, offers the British a prime opportunity to re-think their cozy relationship with their intelligence service.

Translated from the German by Christopher Sultan

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
33 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. optional
spon-facebook-1163175301 08/21/2013
Based on the latest CDU poll numbers, what makes this author think that the German public is any less complacent than that of the UK?
2. Enigma
Tosiek 08/21/2013
German military texts encrypted using the Enigma machine were first broken by the Polish Cipher Bureau in December 1932. This success was a result of efforts by three Polish cryptologists Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski, all working at the time for Polish military intelligence. From 1938 onwards, additional complexity was repeatedly added to the Enigma machines, making the initial decryption techniques increasingly unsuccessful. Nonetheless, the Polish breakthrough represented a vital basis for the later British continuation and effort.
3. British Pragmatism
TheOligarch.Com 08/21/2013
It seems to me the beauty of Germany is your passion. You alone seem to care, but the irony of your great Teutonic will to power is that when you turn your mind to politics you are idealists. The liberal principles underpinning the political philosophy of modern Europe have drifted away from reality- by allowing waves of immigrant destroying social cohesion, liberalism has annihilated itself and created the need for a police state and limits to personal expression and individualism. In the UK we can see that better than in Germany because we are less easily duped by kool-aid sophistry. If you want to save the world Spiegel, do not preach ideology, find a real German scientist / entrepreneur with a calculated not oratorical mind to talk about wind and nuclear power. Show us your inner Achilles by publishing not sophist ideology but practical expert advice on how we can win this war against climate change. That's what we want from Germany, sleeves rolled about fighting man talk, not philosiphical lectures.
4.
devolutionmatters 08/21/2013
There are many things wrong with what happened to David Miranda, but to say that there's a 'cozy complacency' about the response in Britain is absurd. A major political storm is developing, as well as various court actions against the UK Government. All this has been very thoroughly covered by the Guardian, the BBC and some other news outlets (though not the Telegraph, quoted here).
5. optional
peter.walker4087 08/21/2013
As a British citizen I remain deeply troubled that in spite of the serious revelations in the Guardian provided by Snowdon on surveillance techniques, most citizens are unmoved by just how pervasive these security operations are. People seem disinterested when those few who do bother to care point out that powerful institutions such as GCHQ far from safeguarding our freedom and privacy are eroding them. Such power usually corrupts and we all know that absolute power corrupts absolutely. Is this what the British people are sleep walking towards?
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from World section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH





European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Chamber of Deputies Passes Jobs Act

Gang Boss and Weekend Paramedic


Facebook
Twitter