'Hateful' Speech in Istanbul Erdogan Throws Fuel on Flames

He cleared out Gezi Park with brutal violence, disparaged the protesters as terrorists and railed against the foreign media. After a brief conciliatory respite, Prime Minster Erdogan is inflaming the conflict in Turkey once more. But the protest movement shows no signs of backing down.


By and

For a short time it looked as if Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan would relent, as if he had learned something from the revolt against his government that has taken place over the past weeks.

In the middle of the week, he met with demonstrators who are commited to the preservation of Istanbul's Gezi Park. He said that judges would deliberate on the future of the controversial park and held out the prospect of a referendum. Would Erdogan, the despot of the past two weeks, transform himself into a mediator? Since Sunday night at the latest, the answer has been a resounding no.

At a rally in Ankara on Saturday, Erdogan reiterated that he was reaching the limits of his patience. After night fell, his security forces put these words into force. They used bulldozers to clear out Gezi Park, which had become a symbol of the resistance in recent days. They chased protesters and beat them down with clubs, and they shot tear gas into cafes and hotels as the people fled. Doctors who treated the wounded were arrested.

But on Sunday, demonstrators in Turkey returned to the streets to protest the government. At the same time Erdogan gave a memorable speech in Istanbul. Liberal commentators described it as "frightening" and "hateful."

Hundreds of thousands of Erdogan supporters who had been bussed in from throughout the region gathered in a field along the coast. They carried Turkish flags and portraits of the prime minister. Officials with Erdogan's Justice and Development Party (AKP), including European Union Affairs Minister Egemin Bagis, spurred on the crowd.

Erdogan Agitates Conflict

Then Erdogan took to the stage. His supporters chanted "Turkey! Turkey!" as he raised his arms triumphantly. Of one thing there is no doubt: The Turkish premier did not come to Istanbul as a mediator. And it was conflict he was looking for -- not reconciliation.

Erdogan evoked a Turkish Empire, greeting his supporters in the Balkans, in Angola and in Iraq. "Where is Sarajevo? Where is Gaza tonight?" he called out. His voice cracked, and, at that moment, he no longer seemed like the democratically elected prime minister of one of the world's largest economies. Instead he struck the figure of a crazed despot.

Erdogan then addressed the foreign media: "CNN, Reuters, leave us alone with your lies!" he exclaimed. For days now, Erdogan has sought to discredit the protests -- which began as a campaign against the demolition of a park in Istanbul and expanded into a nationwide revolt against the AKP-led government -- as a conspiracy conducted by foreign powers. "These forces want to harm Turkey," he said.

Finally, he addressed the protesters directly, once again calling them terrorists and plunderers. They aren't real Turks, Erdogan said, adding that they should be handled with caution. "Those who work against Turkey will tremble with fear," he warns, adding that he will hold accountable any hotelier who hides these "terrorists."

Erdogan's speech may yet prove to be fateful for the leader. The atmosphere is already charged, and now Erdogan is throwing more fuel on the fire. Rather than reach out to the protesters, he disparages them. But with each attack he is only driving more people out onto the street. Early on, the protest proved effective at bringing together citizens from various social backgrounds.

As Erdogan spoke on Sunday, young demonstrators in Istanbul watched the speech on television -- students, artists, lawyers. They were stunned and unable to believe their prime minister has denounced them as enemies of the state.

"Istanbul, are we one? Istanbul, are we united? Istanbul, are we brothers?" Erdogan shouted after nearly two hours. By this point, a few kilometers away, tens of thousands of demonstrators had once more gathered at Taksim Square. Despite the police and their clouds of tear gas, the protesters continued to march and demand Erdogan's resignation.


Discuss this issue with other readers!
1 total post
Show all comments
Page 1
vtam370 06/18/2013
1. rather economical with the truth
Enough information was left out of this article to make it entirely misleading. I will try to fill in some important details that were intentionally left out. Not to put too fine a point on it, the hate language originated in the social media and Erdogan's reaction is incredibly restrained in light of what I have seen. My facebook page has been overflowing with hate language for three weeks. Somebody wished for a coup d'etat to hang Erdogan. Another made a visceral joke about Gezi Park trees and Erdogan's wife. Others were fabricating lies, doctoring photographs to portray violent Italian police as violent Turkish police or a victim of a traffic accident as a victim of police violence. The protestors have been tweeting the names of banks and restaurants which were deemed as close to government and therefore legitimate targets. Outside the social media, in the streets, a lady with her child in a pram was attacked and abused by violent demonstrators because she was wearing a headscarf. A violent crowd with visible hate in their eyes, have been clashing with the riot police and distubing social order to make headlnes around the world. Yesterday night they were rioting right outside the street where I live, I had to walk through this nefarious crowd to reach home because they had closed the road to traffic. Turkey has been holding free elections since 1950 when the then 'National Chief' was pushed into a corner by opposition from within his own party. The government has also agreed to hold a plebiscite to determine the future of Gezi Park, the apparent cause of the rioting. However, the rioters will not go home. They are not protesting against government policy which can be changed. They are protesting against Erdogan's right to govern Turkey in spite of an impressive series of election victories. They want veto power in a political system that only recognises majority rule because they are afraid that democratic rule could overturn 80 years of militant secularism. This editorial leaves much to be desired in providing a complete and balanced picture of the political violence in Turkey's streets.
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.