Ergenekon Verdicts: Erdogan Silences Dissent in Divided Turkey

By in Istanbul

Photo Gallery: Verdict in Ergenekon Trial Photos
AFP

A Turkish court on Monday announced verdicts and long prison sentences for dozens of defendants in the so-called 'Ergenekon' plot to overthrow the government. The rulings expose how uncertain and divided the country is.

Ergenekon is the name of a valley in the east of Turkey. Legend has it that the few Turks who survived a disastrous defeat fled there, grew into a strong nation and emerged under the leadership of a gray wolf to found a great empire. Many secular nationalists like the story. The wolf is their emblem.

Now, in a mammoth trial -- one of the most controversial in Turkey's history -- Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has killed the wolf. The proceedings came to an end on Monday with verdicts and long jail sentences for dozens of the 275 defendants in the so-called "Ergenekon" trial.

From the government's point of view, Ergenekon is a network that was plotting a coup. Murders and attacks were to spread fear and chaos --and give the army an excuse to bring down Erdogan to restore peace and order.

The alleged members were described as traitors and terrorists. The defendants mainly included members of the military but also lawyers, authors, journalists and opposition politicians.

'Tragicomic' Accusations

The highest ranked defendant, former chief of staff General Ilker Basbug, was sentenced to life in prison. The court ruled that he was the leader of the Ergenekon group and was primarily responsible for the planned coup. Basbug called the accusations "tragicomical." Several other officers had already been convicted last year for supposedly plotting a coup.

The convictions would seem to be consistent with Erdogan's stated goal of curtailing the political influence of the once all-powerful generals. Indeed, at first glance it's an understandable aim given that the army staged three coups in recent decades and regards itself as the true guardian of the national interest.

But the evidence was questionable, and in some cases non-existent. The government hasn't targeted a small, secret group of conspirators but half the military leadership. Many author, journalists, lawyers, businesspeople and opposition politicians are in jail. Erdogan, many critics are convinced, is waging a witchhunt against his political opponents.

Crackdown on Critics

The trial is symptomatic of an insecure, divided republic where modernisation and Islamization are advancing in equal pace. The divisions aren't always clear and they often zig-zag: here the ordinary people, there the intellectuals; here the religious, there the secularists; here the Kemalists, there the Erdogan supporters. Erdogan has turned the former military dictatorship into a police state.

The story that Ergenekon was part of an even greater conspiracy called "Deep State"-- aimed at bringing the generals back to power -- has become steadily less credible. Erdogan, who has been in power since 2003 and who won a third term in july 2011, increasingly resembles a power-obsessed ruler bent on silencing all opposition. Critics say his aim isn't to submit the military to democratic rule but simply to cement his own grip on power.

The intimidation and the number of arrests has steadily risen in the last 10 years. Many journalists no longer dare to report what's really happening, authors avoid making public appearances and government critics need bodyguards. The anti-terrorism law is an effective instrument of power for the government as the supposed terrorist threat is an accusation that's hard to disprove. It plays on a deep-rooted fear among Turks that someone is trying to destabilize and damage the nation.

While intellectuals deplore the curbs on press freedoms, many Turks continue to applaud Erdogan when he cracks down on supposed enemies of the state. "We show a firm, courageous stance in order to free our country and our people from being troubled by gangs and mafiosi," he said recently, according to the Turkish daily Hürriyet. "No one stands above the law. We are determined to combat illegal gangs."

It is indeed difficult to ignore the string of political murders that Turkey has seen in recent years. The journalist Nedim Sener says the attacks and killings were masterminded by people in government agencies. "The latest protests in Turkey and the reaction show the mindset this government still has," he says.

He has been punished for his criticism: He spent a year in jail and is alleged to be a member of the Ergenekon network.

New York author Paul Auster said a year ago he wouldn't visit Turkey because so many authors and journalists are in prison there for no reason. Erdogan retorted that he had no idea who Auster was and sarcastically remarked: "Oh, we need you very much!"

The general secretary of the ruling, conservative-Islamic AKP party sided with Erdogan. Auster, he said, was probably part of the Ergenekon plot.

Article...
  • For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.
  • Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
10 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. what about assassinations ?
MZeng 08/05/2013
Erhan Timuroglu, Osman Yildirim- Bombed a newspaper HQ building who opposes to government, Alparslan Aslan -A lawyer who assassinated 2 supreme court members, Colonel Mehmet Ulger- Proven involvement with killings of Christian missionaries, Other crimes of this organization is involvement in killing of Christian priests, organizing mass protests, bombings and assassinations. All these involvements are proven by phone tappings, voice records etc. So this is not political court case but about organization whose aim was to destabilize the country. While Christians were killed in Turkey, media criticized for it is being Islamic country, now these people being jailed and Turkey is being criticized again.
2. optional
sailhardy 08/05/2013
The Erdogan dictatorship is destabilising Turkey's position in the world. In attempting to ally itself with the Arab world, Turkey has alienated its former allies, and won no real ones in the region. Erdogan will ultimately wind up a pimple on the back of a new Persian Empire.
3. Dictatorship has many forms
Inglenda2 08/05/2013
The Turkish court, which on Monday announced verdicts and long prison sentences for dozens of defendants in the so-called 'Ergenekon' case, deserves a great deal of thanks from Europe, for showing the sort of country we are dealing with. Of course Erdogan is waging a witch-hunt against his political opponents, but is the alternative any better? The choice is between Islamists and nationalists, leaves little hope for a move towards a functioning democracy, of the type some try to make us believe now exists in other countries. Not without very good reason, did former Chancellor Helmut Kohl in 1982, plan to drastically reduce the number of Turks living in Germany. However, even he (like so many other politicians), would seem to make the mistake of assuming, that a democratically elected leader is nothing more than a dictator for a legally restricted period of time. I would remind, in this respect, the Green party in Germany, of how Adolph Hitler (in order to reduce the consumption of meat), once introduced the day in the week, when citizens were required to eat stew. A forced “vegetarian day” would be little different.
4. Erdogan
kukaramanga 08/06/2013
Is learning from his friends in the US.
5.
kkatac 08/06/2013
Again a great mistake in an article about Turkey. Ergenekon is not a place in eastern Turkey. It is a mythological place, as some researchers claim, in the Atlay Mt. I think your writers has been doing such mistakes as trying to finish their articles in time. Hence, the quality of analysis of the article is become less reliable. Hope you staff give some caution to the details. B&R.
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from World section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2013
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH



Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: Ankara Bullies Protesters

Photo Gallery
Photo Gallery: A Divided Turkey


European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Renzi Ups the Pace

50 Italians Fighting with ISIS


Facebook
Twitter