Mad King Ludwig? Study Claims Bavarian Monarch Was Sane

By Frank Thadeusz

Photo Gallery: Not-So-Crazy King Ludwig Photos
DPA

People have long believed that Bavarian King Ludwig II, the man responsible for building the famous castle of Neuschwanstein, was mentally ill. Indeed, he was dethroned for that very reason. But a recent study casts doubt on that diagnosis.

When the fate of the king of Bavaria was placed into his hands, Bernhard von Gudden was a highly regarded figure in medical circles. Not only had the doctor perfected a machine that could cut human brains into fine slices for research purposes. But he had also made a name for himself in the area of psychiatry, which was still in its infancy at the time, with a pioneering proposition. Gudden argued that so-called "moral treatment," which often involved inflicting violence on mental health patients, wasn't perhaps the best curative regimen.

Still, the psychiatrist thoroughly botched his most famous case. The doctor, together with several colleagues, provided the following diagnosis: "He is teetering like a blind man without guidance on the verge of a precipice." The king in question was Ludwig II, the most famous of Bavaria's monarchs, both for his moniker of "Mad King Ludwig" and for the fact that he built several picturesque castles that still dot the southern German state today, including the famous Neuschwanstein at the foot of the Alps.

Gudden et. al. declared Ludwig II unfit to conduct government business. The diagnosis led to Ludwig's being dethroned on June 10, 1886. Three days later he -- and, mysteriously, Gudden -- drowned in what is now called Lake Starnberg, located just south of Munich.

But how accurate was this drastic medical report? Did it stem from a proper examination that lived up to medical standards of the time? And who had an interest in Ludwig II being toppled? These questions have now been addressed by a group led by Mannheim-based psychiatrist Heinz Häfner.

No Evidence

Their findings, recently published in the journal History of Psychiatry, contradict the conclusions reached by Gudden. Häfner says that at no time did the king's behavior "provide reliable evidence of his purported mental illness."

Many historians have refrained from questioning the conclusion that the king from the House of Wittelsbach was mentally ill. After all, Ludwig gave his contemporaries ample reasons to question his sanity. He plunged his kingdom into massive debt with his megalomaniac construction projects. And he countered warnings that he wouldn't be permitted to complete ongoing construction projects by threatening to commit suicide.

Furthermore, he threatened one ill-mannered servant with deportation to America. He wanted to forbid another underling from putting milk in his coffee. He even confounded members of his family with his enervating behavior. But did that warrant his being declared insane?

Heinz Häfner found out that Ludwig was hard-working, contrary to his reputation. Each year, his majesty reviewed 800 documents pertaining solely to domestic Bavarian affairs. A few days before he was dethroned, the king had worked his way through a pile of papers which he signed and sent to the relevant ministries. Ludwig conducted government business far more quickly than his predecessor Maximilian II, Häfner remarked.

If anything, Gudden's diagnosis of paranoia and insanity casts a dim light on the doctor's own decidedly odd methods. Instead of examining the king himself, he based his report on interviews with a few of his aides in secret night-time meetings.

Embarrassing Monarch

"By the way, a personal examination has just confirmed the written evaluation," Gudden telegraphed to the chairman of the Bavarian Council of Ministers, Johann von Lutz. That, however, was a bald-faced lie.

Ludwig's removal from power brought his uncle, Luitpold, onto the throne as prince regent. But this coup had less to do with a thirst for power than with a combination of understandable motives.

Ludwig hadn't just angered his family and come close to driving his country to financial ruin. He also embarrassed the Bavarian royal family at every opportunity. War Minister Joseph Maximilian von Maillinger, for example, was forced to leave office in 1885, partly because the gay monarch couldn't refrain from recruiting his lovers from a cavalry unit, the Bavarian Chevau-légers.

As such, Gudden's misguided diagnosis was far from unwelcome. The lethal outcome was probably unintended, but couldn't be ruled out given that Ludwig faced the prospect of being confined to a royal cell in the Berg palace on the shores of Lake Starnberg, with barred windows, doors with observation slits and no handles. Harsh treatment for a man whose behavior these days would be regarded at worst as the product of a personality disorder.

It is a diagnosis that countless people live with these days, without being locked away.

Article...
For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.

Post to other social networks

Comments
Discuss this issue with other readers!
8 total posts
Show all comments
    Page 1    
1. gay?
annette 01/31/2014
King Ludwig was rumoured to have affairs with stable boys, but also to have had an affair with his cousin, Empress Elisabeth (more commonly known as "Sissi"). To simply call him gay the way it has been done here does not do him justice. For all it looks like, he was most probably a very flamboyant bisexual.
2. Good King Ludwig
ontologix 02/01/2014
Although I am happy about the general tendency of this article because it does away with several myths, the author has copied several common errors about Ludwig. First of all Ludwig did not drive Bavaria close to financial collapse. He spent ten per cent more than his civil list would have allowed. Current politicians can only dream of such financial problems. Secondly there is no hard evidence that he ever actually had sex with a male lover, although he probably was gay and enjoyed bizarre parties with soldiers. He also was an eccentric character, but conducted his royal duties carefully, as the Prussian ambassador in Bavaria observed. But generally the article is praiseworthy. Nobody declared the Prussian militarist Kaiser William II insane. William invested into the German fleet and did not stop the outbreak of WW I. Where is his fleet now? Ludwig invested in his castles. They yield a substantial annual profit, especially Neuschwanstein which attracts more than a millions tourists from all over the world each year. The German fleet, which rests on the seabed, cost many times more than Ludwig´s castles. Moreover he was a pacifist and hated war. When the Prussians united Germany he refused to go to the Versailles proclamation commenting "If this unification under Prussian leadership goes ahead it will result in a catastrophe for Europe." How right he was. Moreover he was a social reformer and did a lot for the emancipation of his poorer and humbler subjects. This explains his immense popularity during his lifetime. I believe that he was shot when trying to escape with the help of his cousin Elizabeth of Austria. The article claims he was drowned in Lake Starnberg. This is not correct. The post mortem stated that there was no water in his lungs. So he must have died of another cause. it would be correct to say that he was found dead in Lake Starnberg. Doctor Gudden, however, was drowned. The only thing I do not like about him is that he financed much of Wagner´s operas.
3. Mad King Ludwig?
Rev. Stefan Jonasson 02/01/2014
It seems to me that Frank Thadeusz's reasoning in this article falls short in two ways. Firstly, after criticizing Dr. Bernhard von Gudden for having failed to examine King Ludwig personally, Mr. Thadeusz then proceeds to cite as authoritative the conclusions of a psychiatrist and his team who likewise haven't examined the king personally and who are presuming to second-guess Dr. Gudden's diagnosis a century and a quarter later. Secondly, seemingly confident that King Ludwig suffered from a personality disorder rather than insanity, per se, Mr. Thadeusz concludes by declaring this a "diagnosis that countless people live with these days, without being locked away." Well, that may be true, but none of them are King of Bavaria, either!
4. King Ludwig II
casement 02/01/2014
In fact, many people are still locked away for less.
5. Could Ludwig have had a drub abuse problem?
Macadore 02/01/2014
Having visited many sites that Ludwig built and being familiar with the traditional story, I wonder if Ludwig frequently used hashish or some other drug.
Show all comments
    Page 1    
Keep track of the news

Stay informed with our free news services:

All news from SPIEGEL International
Twitter | RSS
All news from Zeitgeist section
RSS

© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2014
All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH



  • Print Send
  • Feedback
  • Comment | 8 Comments
From DER SPIEGEL


European Partners
Presseurop

Politiken

Corriere della Sera

Napolitano’s Positive Balance

A&F Guilty of Age Discrimination


Facebook
Twitter