Germany and the Puigdemont Case 'Politicians Need To Stay Out of This'

Following Carles Puigdemont's arrest on Sunday, Germany has landed smack in the middle of the Catalan independence battle. Politicians here say it's up to the judiciary to decide whether to extradite the former president of Catalonia, but the issue is nonetheless politically charged.

Carles Puigdemont during a protest in Brussels in December

Carles Puigdemont during a protest in Brussels in December


The conflict was never really that far away. Right in the middle of the European Union, in the most popular destination country for German vacationers, the Spanish government and Catalan separatists have been sparring heavily with each other. The German government has always tried to stay out of the conflict. Officials have stated repeatedly that what is happening in Catalan is a domestic conflict that needs to be solved peacefully and within the scope of the Spanish constitution.

Now this: Catalan separatist leader Carles Puigdemont is sitting in a German jail after his arrest on Sunday by German police as he was traveling back from a speech in Finland to Belgium, where he has been staying for months now. Police conducted the arrest after Spain issued a European Arrest Warrant. Suddenly, Germany, which only swore in its new government just days ago, is right at the center of the battle between the Spanish central government and Catalan independence efforts.

A Case for the Judiciary

Officially, the government in Berlin is maintaining its position that it will not interfere politically in the domestic conflict -- especially when it comes to the currently pending court proceedings relating to Puigdemont's possible extradition. And in this special case, German federalism may actually be helpful to the federal government. The universal line in Berlin is that the judiciary in the state of Schleswig-Holstein will be responsible for deciding on whether to extradite Puigdemont.

Puigdemont on March 22 in Helsinki, Finland
imago/ Agencia EFE

Puigdemont on March 22 in Helsinki, Finland

Justice officials in Germany's northernmost state will have to address the case. It could take up to two weeks for the higher regional court in Schleswig to rule on whether to extradite the Catalan politician. On Monday, a district court in Neumunster ordered Puigdemont's detainment until the higher regional court makes its ruling, citing risk of flight.

International Newsletter: Sign up for our newsletter -- and get the very best of SPIEGEL in English sent to your email inbox twice weekly.

The 55-year-old former president of Catalonia has become a symbolic figure for other separatists across Europe, but in Spain, the central government views Puigdemont as a man guilty of several crimes. Following the referendum on Catalonia's independence in October 2017, an act the central government in Spain considered illegal, proceedings have been opened against Puigdemont on charges of "rebellion" and "sedition." Many of his fellow separatists are currently in jail in Spain.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel's spokesman, Steffen Seibert, said on Monday that the Spanish government has repeatedly pointed out "that Puigdemont and others aren't being sought for their political views, but for concrete criminal matters." The conflict over Catalonia, he said, must be "solved within Spain's legal and constitutional systems," which is why the German government has supported the actions of the Spanish government in this conflict. "Spain is a democratic constitutional state," Seibert said.

German Justice Minister Katarina Barley of the center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) on Monday referred queries to the justice authorities in Schleswig-Holstein. And German Foreign Minister Heike Maas of the SPD, who was on his first trip to Israel since taking office, and officials at the Interior Ministry also offered no comment.

But even if German officials are playing it cool, the latest developments in the Puigdemont case are indeed politically explosive for Berlin.

The German government is convinced separatist movements pose a threat to the cohesion of the European Union. So far, at least, Berlin has rejected taking on a mediating role in the crisis. And there are no signs that the new government is likely to view this any differently than the outgoing one, even if some in the coalition are gently encouraging a mediation mission. "The increasing militancy of a part of the independence movement does not bode well," Rolf Mützenich, the deputy head of the SPD group in the German parliament, told SPIEGEL. "The German government could take an active role in mediation efforts at the European level."

Mützenich is highly critical of Sunday's arrest. "The judges will no doubt conduct an in-depth legal review of the case while considering the leeway available to them," he said. "But politically, I consider Puigdemont's arrest to be questionable," added the SPD politician, a foreign policy expert, who also said his skepticism is based on the role played by some elements in the Spanish judiciary. "Certain Spanish judges appear to be following political guidance. But lasting peace in the conflict with Barcelona can only be obtained if the central government is serious about it and prepared to make compromises." He said the EU needs to finally step up and use its options for making "the consequences of their actions clear to all involved."

The Tone in Berlin: Stay Out of It

You get an altogether different view if you speak to representatives of the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), who share power with the SPD as the senior partner in Germany's coalition government. CDU domestic affairs and legal expert Volker Ullrich warned against allowing the situation to get "politically charged." He said German politicians should not intervene in the extradition proceedings.

It will be hard enough just preventing that impression. From a legal perspective, there are no objections to Puigdemont's arrest, "but it creates big political problems," Alexander Graf Lambsdorff, the foreign policy point man for the business-friendly Free Democratic Party (FDP) told the Augsburger Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper. He said the extradition proceedings would make Germany a party to an internal Spanish conflict -- a development that Belgium, where Puigdemont had been staying, has itself tried to avoid at all costs.

Fellow party member Bijan Dir-Sarai, the foreign policy spokesman for the SPD's party group in parliament, said that Germany could not take sides in the conflict. "What we are dealing with here is a legal matter, not a foreign policy issue," he said. Meanwhile, Omid Nouripour, a foreign policy expert with the Green Party, viewed the situation similarly. "Whether Puigdemont will be extradited will be determined by the judiciary -- politicians need to stay out of this."

The most critical comments came from Andrej Hunko, the European policy spokesman for the far-left Left Party's parliamentary group. He said Puigdemont's arrest had been a "disgrace" and ordered the separatist leader's release. But the party appears to be alone on that point.

Related Topics

Discuss this issue with other readers!
3 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
ian_mackenzie 03/27/2018
1. Catalon
If what Puigdemont did is not sedition and rebellion, what in the world is? Granted I come from a place (USA) where the whole secession issue caused a lot of trouble and where we have no confusion anymore about who can or cannot secede--I suppose Puerto Rico could leave and no one would notice--but any serious attempt of a state to secede is sedition and rebellion and will be treated maximally. The Spanish constitution seems pretty clear about this--so if Catalonia, or any other region wants to secede, agitate to change the constitution. They don't want to try the legal way because it is HARD and leaves time for passions to cool. i.e. they would lose.
jamawani 03/28/2018
2. Re: Puigdemont Arrest
It is stunning how Germany's political leadership is jumping through every possible hoop to absolve themselves of any moral responsibility in the arrest of Carles Puigdemont this past weekend. Need one remind Germany that is was responsible for the extradition of Lluis Companys to Francoist Spain and, thus, for his execution? The bitter irony is not lost on the Catalan people. If the SPD accedes to a German government position of "allowing the process to take its course" then it has lost any and all legitimacy as a social left party. And it deserves to be discarded on the trash bin of history. Not to mention the hypocrisy of all major German parties - - Germany welcomed, even abetted, the break-up of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union. If Latvia and Croatia not only were deserving of independence, but also of E.U. membership, then why not Catalonia? Moreso, Catalonia has a larger population and a far more developed economy than either Latvia or Croatia. But the real kicker is that while the SPD supported Latvian and Croatian independence - countries that have had a significant fascist past - it fails to support Catalan independence, a country with a strong socialist heritage. Where is the "social" these days in the Social Democratic Party?
dinerouk61 04/01/2018
3. Puidgmont
'The German government is convinced separatist movements pose a threat to the cohesion of the European Union'. That is the reason that Germany became involved. Germany, as we all know, has been one of the big movers and shakers of the EU, and thus cannot stand by and watch the further defragmentation of their beloved club, following the audacious British move to leave! It is determined to show the rest of Europe that the EU/Germany will crack down on such cavalier attempts by factions to break away, for as we know, Independence is anathema to the EU rulers!
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.