'We Are Stubborn' Refugees Still Set on Germany Despite Border Controls

Germany introduced controls on its border with Austria on Sunday to slow down the influx of refugees coming into the country. The hope is for an EU-wide quota deal to share the burden. The refugees themselves, though, still hope they'll end up in Germany.


By in Vienna

Evrim, a refugee from the ravaged Syrian city of Aleppo, has wrapped herself in a wool blanket, her red sweatshirt no longer offering sufficient protection against the cold. The young woman with dyed-blonde hair would rather spend the night in front of Vienna's Westbahnhof Station than sleep in an emergency shelter. She is planning on taking the very first train to Germany the next morning.

"We heard that Germany has closed the border," Evrim says. But she doesn't really want to believe it. She heard the news from Mohammed, who is also from Aleppo and is part of the group of 15 Kurds from Syria she is traveling with. The group coalesced on the refugee trail, which leads from Turkey across the Western Balkans to Hungary and beyond. Mohammed, for his part, heard the news from a British journalist who had interviewed the group in the early evening right after they crossed into Austria from Hungary. "Maybe he misunderstood (the journalist)," Evrim says.

But he wasn't mistaken. On Sunday evening, Germany introduced temporary border controls along its frontier with Austria in response to the massive numbers of refugees that have been making their way to Germany in recent weeks. Officials from Germany's 16 states sounded the alarm back on Thursday, warning that refugee hostels were full and that they could no longer process the huge numbers of newcomers.

The temporary border controls -- which could last as long as two weeks, according to Bavarian Interior Minister Joachim Herrmann, who spoke on public radio on Monday morning -- are intended to give Germany a chance to catch its breath while at the same time ratcheting up the pressure on other European Union member states to accept a quota system for the distribution of asylum recipients across the bloc. EU interior ministers are meeting on Monday to try to find a solution.

Graphic: The refugee route to Europe.

Graphic: The refugee route to Europe.

German Interior Minister Thomas de Maizière made the announcement on Sunday, soon after hundreds of federal police officers began making their way to Germany's border with Austria. In his statement, de Maizière said that the Dublin Regulations, which require that refugees register and remain in the country where they first set foot on EU territory, remain in effect -- even if Germany, along with Austria, Hungary and other member states, had largely ignored the requirement in recent weeks. "I demand that all European member states again adhere (to Dublin) in the future," the German interior minister said. Refugees, he added, "can't simply choose" in which country they want to apply for asylum.

To ensure that refugees don't merely change their route and find their way to Germany by way of the Czech Republic, border controls may also be introduced along that frontier as well. "The task is to prevent illegal border crossings," Saxony Interior Minister Markus Ulbig told public broadcaster MDR Info on Monday. "That means that controls may be introduced."

For the refugees, that means that Austria, suddenly, is no longer just a transit country. It could become their new home. But the 15 Syrian Kurds in front of the train station want to hear nothing of the sort. "We will wait as long as it takes for Germany to reopen its borders," says Evrim. "We are Kurds. We are stubborn."

Why Germany?

That seems to be the viewpoint of most migrants. Around 10,000 of them arrived in Austria from Hungary on Sunday, but only a few dozen of them applied for asylum in the country. The overwhelming majority want to move on. But why to Germany?

"My husband is there," says a young woman from the Kurdish town of Afrin in Syria. She has lived for the past two years in Turkey, like all of those in the group. Her husband left a year ago and received asylum in Germany. But because he only was able to get an appointment at the German Embassy in Ankara in 2016 to apply to bring his family to Germany as well, his wife decided to make the trip herself, with the help of migrant smugglers.

Sixteen-year-old Mohammed, who is traveling with his sister, says: "My brother lives there." His brother, Mohammed adds, has been in Germany for the last four years and is going to university there. He advised his siblings to join him. "We were in Istanbul for the last two years," Mohammed says. "But we don't have a future there. I won't be able to go to university in Turkey. It's hard enough just to go to school."

There are at least 1.7 million Syrians currently living in Turkey, but according to Turkish law, they do not have refugee status. Rather, they are seen merely as guests who enjoy temporary protection -- and they are not allowed to work. Furthermore, more than 80 percent of them do not live inside a refugee camp, meaning that they receive no support. Their situation is becoming increasingly difficult. It is a similar plight to the one facing Syrians who have found refuge in Jordan and Lebanon.

Evrim is the only one in the group who does not have family in Germany. "Germany can't just close itself off," she says. "Where should we go? What should I do in Austria? I don't know anything about Austria. We are foreign there. I want to go to Germany. There are so many Syrians in Germany. We aren't foreigners there." The fact that there may not even be a cot available to her in Munich doesn't dissuade her. "Thus far on this trip, nothing has been easy or free."

'We'll Just Continue on Foot'

The meeting of European Union interior ministers on Monday will go a long way toward determining whether EU member states are willing to accept a quota system, such that Germany does not continue to bear the brunt of the influx. De Maizière on Sunday sketched out a scenario involving the establishment of reception/registration centers in Hungary, Italy and Greece, from which refugees could then be distributed across the bloc. Eastern European countries, however, have thus far resisted the proposal.

On Monday, Bavarian Governor Horst Seehofer, who has been extremely critical of Chancellor Angela Merkel's handling of the refugee influx and who invited Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán to visit Bavaria to discuss the crisis, insisted that the reintroduction of border controls was necessary to "bring order back to the entire system." Speaking prior to a meeting of senior party leaders in Munich, Seehofer said: "Every logical person" saw that the situation couldn't continue as it had in recent days. But, he added: "We remain a humane and helping state."

Meanwhile, German Transportation Minister Alexander Dobrindt said that refugees will still be brought into Germany using special trains. "There will certainly be some (trains) arriving in the coming days and weeks," he said.

Evrim, meanwhile, is making plans to continue her journey. She has heard that Austrian trains were heading to towns near the border with Germany. She didn't know if they would take refugees along, but she wants to try. "I have been on the road for 17 days. Ten of those days I spent in Greece. If we can somehow get close to the border, then we'll just continue on foot to Germany."

Discuss this issue with other readers!
14 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
lisa.galea 09/14/2015
1. Southern Europe can smirk
Southern Europe can smirk. Now that it hit Germany and other Northern borders it is a problem. It has been a problem in the South since 1999. But that is Europe!
marcuspratt 09/14/2015
This naive, foolish, and ignorant attempt at erasing the stains and sins of the past by opening up your borders to millions of refugees didn't work out? By the time this is over, this may very well be the most stupid idea ever and the premier example of German hubris. Good luck mopping up this disaster and getting the mobs out. You made your bed and now you must sleep in it.
gialc 09/14/2015
3. The real problemaren't the migrants per se.
The real problem is incompetent politicians who have no concept of what to do. No clue whatsoever. This despite of the fact that the migration problem developed slowly over the last few years. It was known to everybody who even remotely looked at the world. EU politicians from all parties simply looked the other way. They failed their people. Now, Germans will pay for Greece (and the EU in general), seek to pacify Mr. Putin (who faces economic collapse at home), help Brazil's rain forest, and "integrate" the 800,000 refugees - and their relatives who will follow in the next two years - into its social structure. Good luck. And - please don't blame the Americans for this failure of EU politicians. Peter Scholla
nsmith 09/14/2015
4. Just Wondering...
Since when do refugees get to dictate which country in Europe they will go to? If indeed they were so truly persecuted in their native land, wouldn't they just be thankful to register in the first country they landed in??? Instead of demanding to go another one with better benefits...like Germany???
joshuaelias57 09/14/2015
5. Compassion with No Vision
Compassion with no foresight towards a future Europe. Through resolute force and civil wars Europe is committed to becoming Muslim. I am most likely the naive American who asks why the trail, the exile leads to Germany and in particular Bavaria, the most financially thriving spot in Europe....If the matter is solely for economic wealth, better quality of living, and standards of living...the wealthiest of nations, Arab nations Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, have failed to lift a finger or open a doors within their countries. They have turned their backs. Western Europe is quickly becoming a suburb of Turkey and the Arab world under the guise of compassion. This is astounding and I guarantee 90 percent of those Germans that think this is a good deed and good thing will be the first to complain and criticize within a year or two. This is another strong and I imagine a calculated move to dissolve all things Western, including beautiful artworks, museum, Culture...under the illusion of compassion....perhaps its too late to wake up.
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.