Joseph Beuys New Letter Debunks More Wartime Myths


Part 2: A Self-Made Hero

On the one hand, Beuys depicts Laurinck as a larger-than-life figure and super-pilot. "Life was no problem for Hanne," he writes. "He stood in the middle of it all, a laughing victor." On the other hand, Beuys paints the pilot as the more impetuous one, as being almost frivolous. "Hanne had a lot of bad luck in his time on the front, a lot of failures, a lot of trouble, things that might have made another man bitter," Beuys writes. "But after a bad experience of that sort, Hanne would be singing his favorite songs -- just as beautifully, just as wonderfully -- firm in his beliefs (in his own flying abilities, as well)."

It was an abbreviated life, one tailored to the requirements of war. Like Beuys, Laurinck was a boy from the countryside. Beuys was from Kleve, a town in western Germany near the Dutch border; Laurinck was from Vreden, a town about 60 kilometers (37 miles) northeast of Kleve. Both men grew up under the Nazi dictatorship, and both joined the Luftwaffe soon after finishing high school. At the time, many saw the German air force as a good place to become a hero.

Did Laurinck sense, however, that there could be another kind of life? As can be seen in a letter he wrote to his sister, he wanted to get engaged and seemed tired of being a pilot.

And Beuys? By the end of the war, he would experience hand-to-hand combat in what must have been terrible carnage. He never talked about these experiences later, only speaking generally of the "shit" that soldiers found themselves in and saying that participating in the fighting had been the morally correct thing to do.

A recently aired German TV series called "Unsere Mütter, Unsere Väter" ("Our Mothers, Our Fathers") tells the story of the war generation that Beuys belonged to. These are stories of young people, many of whom were lured in and then wrung dry by their regime. And, after the war, they were no longer capable of connecting to themselves or their guilt.

Beuys' 1944 letter gives the impression of a person much like those featured in the TV series -- someone who wanted to be a hero, but ended up being lured into something terrible instead. Beuys did achieve his dream of becoming a hero, but that would only come later, when he became a superstar of the modern art scene rather than as a soldier.

And he achieved that in part because of the way he mythologized his past in the war and especially in Crimea: elevating himself from radio operator to dive-bomber pilot; making himself the victim of enemy artillery fire, although it was actually poor weather that brought his plane down from the sky; and transforming the people who pulled him from the plane's wreckage into Tatar shamans, although his 1944 letter says they were Russian workers.

And while Beuys became part of an important new movement in West Germany, a recently published biography of the artist by author Hans Peter Riegel suggests that Beuys still remained an anachronistic figure, never quite able to break free from his earlier enthusiasm for nationalist ideology. Beuys attended gatherings of old comrades and sought out contact with former Nazis, Riegel shows. In 1980, Beuys admitted he had initially signed up for Hitler's army out of a "feeling of belonging and solidarity with others my age."

As an artist and professor, Beuys was no longer the periphery figure that he was in that wartime photograph from Crimea. Instead, he was the focal point of a new avant-garde. He saw himself as someone singled out and special -- and eventually others saw him that way, too. Yet this early letter shows a Joseph Beuys who was smaller, more assimilated and more average than he later wanted to see himself.

Translated from the German by Ella Ornstein

Discuss this issue with other readers!
5 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
pcohen 07/13/2013
1. Beuys
The writer of this piece is a fiction writer, not much of a journalist. Simply unbelievable, this abuse of an artist for self inflation pruposes.
romyle 07/13/2013
2. Beuys
This is a harsh treatment. Is the writer implying the Beuys was a fake? Rather, it seems that this man, who had horrifying experiences in his early life, tried to make something positive come from it. He could easily have turned in on himself, become angry, violent, addicted. But he did not. He became an artist and an advocate for good causes. What is scurrilous about that?
Deep_Thought_42 07/14/2013
3. Artists Are Human Too
@pcohen: Sorry, I cannot share your view. New primary documents from Beuys himself, written 1944 close after the plane crash, were found, which tell another story than those, which Josef Beuys told after the war. Not more, not less. An artist is subject to public interest, therefore it was published. I do not see any abuse by the author of this article. Beuys, Warhol etc. have been hyped by followers and especially the art business to god-like status. They are not gods, they are all human and can make mistakes.
Emmanuel 07/15/2013
4. Beuys?
Beuys' myths were debunked long ago and with more insight, look to Benjamin Buchloch. It is facile to link the real-life Joseph Beuys to Nazis, he openly acknowledged it. Artists do different things, but many are myth makers. The issue is not if the real-life Joseph Beuys was rescued from Tatars who rubbed fat all over his flaccid body. The issue should be if the myth has richness and vitality today and if the artist persona which Beuys constructed is relevant. Beuys did recognize the power of celebrity and persona. As a non-European viewing it from the outside, both the real-life Joseph Beuys and the artist persona Beuys offer me insight into post-war European experience. That is somewhat of an historical and anecdotal luxury and not necessarily interesting in a 21st century dialogue of art and value.
Emmanuel 07/15/2013
5. Peter Fend, Martin Kippenberger
"All Artists are liars" Peter Fend "Every Artist is a human being" Martin Kippenberger
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.