World from Berlin 'Snowden Had No Other Choice'

Edward Snowden has been granted asylum for one year in Russia in a move that threatens to further strain Russian-American relations. German editorialists warn that cooperation between the countries is essential for solving international crises.

A still photo taken from Russia24 television shows whistleblower Edward Snowden leaving the Moscow airport on Thursday.
AP Photo/Russia24 via Associated Press Television

A still photo taken from Russia24 television shows whistleblower Edward Snowden leaving the Moscow airport on Thursday.

Edward Snowden is partly a free man. Having been granted temporary asylum in Russia, he is able to move around the country, although he is likely to remain under the close watch of the Kremlin. His current location is the subject of mystery because Snowden did not disclose where he was headed before leaving the Moscow airport on Thursday.

In Washington, politicians are outraged by the move by Moscow to grant the whistleblower asylum for one year. White House spokesman Jay Carney said, "We're extremely disappointed that the Russian government would take this step despite our very clear and lawful requests in public and in private to have Mr. Snowden expelled to the United States to face the charges against him. We're evaluating the utility of a summit in light of this and other issues," he added.

Carney was referring to the upcoming G-20 summit in St. Petersburg, even though few seriously believe President Barack Obama will boycott the important meeting of the world's 20 most important industrial and emerging nations. As German public radio station Deutschlandradio noted, "none of the world's major crises -- like Syria, the Middle East or Iran -- can be solved without Russia."

The station quoted one of its correspondents as saying that Russia would have preferred to avoid the scandal but that it saw no other choice but to grant asylum to Snowden given that the US had prevented any other solution. The correspondent described the move as a "targeted provocation".

Although it is unlikely Obama will skip the G-20 summit on Sept. 5, some politicians are calling for it. Democrat Senator Charles Schumer on Thursday accused Russia of "stabbing us in the back" by granting temporary asylum. "Mr. Snowden is a coward who has chosen to run," Schumer said. "Given Russia's decision today, the president should recommend moving the G-20 summit."

In Germany, many of the country's leading media offer commentaries on what Snowden's Russia asylum might mean for Moscow's relations to the US and other countries.

The left-leaning Süddeutsche Zeitung writes:

"Moscow has now given the fleeing American asylum for one year, even though it could lead to considerable tensions with the US. The Kremlin actually wanted to keep that from happening, which is why it had constantly argued that Snowden had not even entered onto Russian soil after his landing. [...] But Russia is used to pressure from the West, and the advantages of the step are obvious to Moscow. The country can now present itself as the defender of a civil rights campaigner who is threatened in his home country with the severest of penalties [...] In other words, it allows Russia to reverse roles -- America becomes the bad guy and it is the West that is criticized for its obsessive spying."

"But Snowden will have to pay a price. He may be safe in Russia, but he will not be free. The American is likely to be strictly monitored. And he will only be allowed to say things outside the country that do not damage Moscow internationally. Otherwise, Russia may be quick to throw him out."

The conservative Die Welt writes:

"Everything has its price. That applies to temporary asylum for Edward Snowden in Putin's Russia as well. In intelligence circles, one has to deliver something in order to get something in return. The most valuable thing in Snowden's suitcase were the NSA's secrets. No one knows better how to use them than the comrades on the opposite side. Commenting on the solution now found (for Snowden), Putin sarcastically remarked that the Snowden case is too small to create a lasting burden for relations with the United States."

"So far it remains an open question whether Snowden will go down in the history of the intelligence services as a hero who wanted to protect the world from incursion from some Internet monster or whether he is just a self-important person in the parallel universe of cyberspace and a betrayer of national security."

The conservative Frankfurter Allegemeine Zeitung writes:

"Edward Snowden knocked on many doors in recent weeks. There were plenty of expressions of sympathy for the young man who, with his betrayal of secrets, shed light on the scope of American spying programs. But despite all the excitement over the obsessive spying, no one wanted to open the door for Snowden. Now, it is Vladimir Putin of all people who has taken blatant pleasure in playing the role of a champion of freedom of opinion and human rights by letting the American stay in Russia for a year. But it's also the same Putin who has taken considerable pleasure in taking political opponents out of action with flimsy charges. Alexei Navalny, the most prominent of them, was just sentenced to five years in a prison camp. His offense? He exposed corruption in the Russian authorities and at state-owned companies."

The Westdeutsche Allgemeine Zeitung, the largest newspaper in the populous Ruhr region of North Rhine-Westphalia, writes:

"Snowden is out of the intermediate world of the Moscow airport and has now entered Russia. Russia of all places, a country that is anything but a flawless democracy. A country in which a former intelligence agent rules the country with an iron fist. But to blame the whistleblower for all this would either be malicious or naïve. Snowden had no other choice."

"Go back to the States? The fate of WikiLeaks informant Bradley Manning shows what happens to people there who uncover government misconduct. Not a single country that could claim to be democratically flawless offered Snowden asylum."

In an editorial, WDR Radio, one of Germany's largest public broadcasters, states:

"Rarely since the end of the Cold War have relations between Moscow and Washington been as frosty as they are right now. A considerable amount of that is attributable to President Barack Obama's manic attempt to persuade Putin to extradite NSA expert and whistleblower Snowden. [...] Obama, constantly alleged to be level-headed when it comes to his analysis, has failed to recognized that a power monger like Putin is far more important to international politics than NSA whistleblower Snowden."

"The US president has made petty revenge a leading principle of his policies. Obama wanted Snowden to be extradited at any cost. Obama didn't hesitate in having his attorney general write a letter to Moscow with logic as follows: We Americans are even willing to forego our classic instruments of torture and the death penalty if you, the Russians, just extradite Snowden to us."

"The letter couldn't have been more telling in terms of Obama's position towards unwelcome whistleblowers and possible betrayers of secrets. To expose himself to an ice cold Machiavelli like Putin with such a laughable position of self-revelation like that speaks volumes about the way in which Obama conducts foreign policy beyond his brilliant speeches."

"If the US president now also commits the error of playing the role of the offended prima donna and not appearing at the G-20 summit in September, then we can forget about relations between Washington and Moscow altogether. That, in turn, would be disastrous for the flashpoints in this world -- regardless whether it be Syria, Iran or the withdrawal of troops form Afghanistan, these crisis regions will all become even more incalculable without a minimum of Russian-American cooperation."

- Daryl Lindsey


Discuss this issue with other readers!
8 total posts
Show all comments
Page 1
peterboyle.4848 08/02/2013
1. A Matter of Style
The US needs Russia more than Russia needs the US. In this exchange the US comes off as the petulant Bully who was thwarted, and Russia looks like the responsible adult who made a logical compromise. No matter what the US does, all of the data that Snowden has will come out. I'm sure that both China and Russia by now has copies of it, but will not release the information directly. In the US, the head of NSA was asked not to attend one Hacker Convention and was booed at the other when he tried to deny the allegations brought by the material that has been released so far. THese conventions are where the NSA has traditionally trolled for new recruits. The major Intelligence agencies around the world are being carefull what they say because they are afraid that further releases will prove they were lying as has happened several times to the US, Germany and GB. US power and influence in the world is ebbing, while Russia and China are gaining in both. Many countries breathed a sigh of relief when Obama was elected to replace G.W. Bush and his Cowboy attitudes, but are growing frustrated that Obama has continued those same policies that he promised to end. Not only has Obama reneged on his promises, but he has been even more agressive in many areas, particularly in going after any who leak about what he is doing and journalists who print those leaks. For Obama to snub Russia now would be one more slippage of US prestige, power and influence. Both GB and the US must realize that they are NOT 'Special Cases' and deserve no special treatment.
peskyvera 08/02/2013
2. optional
And even if Obama decides to skip the meeting, the sun will continue to rise in the East. Life without the US is possible. As for granting asylum to Snowden...the US continues to refuse to extradite a criminal by the name of Posada Carriles, involved in the blowing up of a Cuban airliner some years back. And many other foreign despots and dictators, once supported by the US, walk around free all over the US instead of being brought to justice in their respective countries. The US granting asylum to criminals...Snowden isn't one.
P. MOULIN 08/03/2013
3. European double morality & USA neofascism growing
1) USA/OTAN spying American , Europen, World citizens . All considered all as potential terroristists? European leaders keep in "vassal" silent...? 2) USA / OTAN destruction of Libya and genocide of libyan people and killing panafrican leader Kadhafi..... Today the country in hands of islamic terroristes / mercenaries... Former Lybiam leaders still in prison and under the islamic terrorist "justice" supported by USA/OTAN and EU... like Dr Ahmed Ibrahim have been sentenced to death two days ago under the silent of all EU leaders and media ... We need thousans of Snowden in each country to end with the neofascism growing throught USA and EU...... The USA dark / shadow government .... has been seriouly analized in books like : "The road to 9/11.Wealth, Emire and the Future of America" by Peter Dale Scott Ed 2007 500 pp
fung.pee 08/03/2013
4. The USA stuck on the horns of a dilemma of it's own making
QUOTE: " Russia of all places, a country that is anything but a flawless democracy." This implies the USA is. It is not, it is a self-serving country that lies, and blackmails other countries into submission. The problem is America has met it's match this time. Both Manning and Snowden have re-written Obama's script and he wants them both to pay the price. But it is not they who are at fault, it is the USA - the US government. America has log expected the world to kowtow to it's every wish and now it is discovering that it's power had been diminished in the international arena. It has no money and with no money it loses influence. Thank you Russia for looking after Snowden, his country sure isn't. P.S. I am a US citizen.
Gunar 08/03/2013
5. optional
Logic of Obama letter to Moscow: 'We Americans are even willing to forego our classic instruments of torture and the death penalty if you, the Russians, just extradite Snowden to us'. -- Is that really the logic?? Wonder what the actual words are in that letter.
Show all comments
Page 1

All Rights Reserved
Reproduction only allowed with permission

Die Homepage wurde aktualisiert. Jetzt aufrufen.
Hinweis nicht mehr anzeigen.